If you watched Rock Star Supernova, who do you think should have won?

Question

I was cheering for Dilana the whole show but Lukas won in the end. Do you think he was a better choice than Dilana or did you prefer someone else?

Answer 1

I was hoping Toby or Dilana

Answer 2

From the beginning, I was rooting for Lukas or Magni, so it was nice to see them progress so far. I'm kind of disappointed that Lukas won, if only because I thought his performances simply weren't as good as some of the others.

Dilana started well, but faded toward the end -- and her head's not screwed on too tight.

Toby improved dramatically, and I hope he'll have a great solo career.

And I still miss Storm Large, who I thought was just terrific. I'll buy anything she does in the future.

(A note to the poster above about Dilana's limping: the final Tuesday night performance show was taped on Sunday night, September 10, while the finale was taped Wednesday morning, September 13 -- so she had several more days to heal.)

Answer 3

I personally wanted Magni to win. I think he by far had the best "heavy metal" voice and would best compliment the playing styles of the 3 superstars in the band. I liked all the finalists, but in the case of Lucas I thought he was a little to alternative for me. By alternative I mean very Cure-like. In the end, I think it will be best for Dilana, Toby, and Magni that they did not win this contest. I do not see Supernova becoming a supergroup and if their original music is any indication, I do not think they will put out a second album. Secondly, the person who won this job has the daunting task of being the front man of a group of front man. There is nothing Lucas can do which will compare to the star power of Tommy Lee.

Answer 4

Toby should have gotten it or even Magni. The crowd seemed to feed off their performances much more than Lukas. I admit I liked Dilana from the start but she faded hard in the final weeks. She didn't seem to be able to perform anything current or have much creative spark for her originals.

I didn't really like Lukas from the start. His voice isn't pure his performances seem forced. He'd be better off fronting something more along the lines of Slipknot or Coal Chamber than Supernova.

Answer 5

i thought toby was better then both of them lukas all ways forced his lyrics out but i must admit toby did too in that final billy idol song dilana is a good singer but that whole janis joplin whine thing she dos kinda bugs

Answer 6

Magni! Oh, and did you notice Dilana wasn't limping on the final show, whereas she was the night before.

Answer 7

I really liked the final four, but I wanted Toby to win most of all. He knew how to play to the crowd, and his music style and voice is something that just about anyone can enjoy. Whereas Lukas is more of an aquired taste, with his grating voice and look. I like him, though, but I think Toby should've won.

Answer 8

I knew Lukas would win... he was the best rocker out of them all and he would fit in best with the group. My choices were between Lukas and Tobey, but I thought Lukas was the best. I told my husband at the start of the final who would win... and he did! For all those who say whoever should have won... they should have voted! And if they did vote, they should have voted more. Peace.

Answer 9

i'm sorry, i imagine Lukus sings like he has a mouth finished of doo doo. i imagine Dilana were given ripped off and that i imagine the band had no purpose of letting a lady be their lead singer. perhaps next time they might want to easily enable the adult men audition and then it would not be one of those farce. the entire educate is a FARCE.......

Answer 10

lukas!!!he rawks!!