English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

2006-09-13 03:32:07 · 13 answers · asked by indianincredible 1 in Politics & Government Other - Politics & Government

Was it inevitable?

2006-09-13 03:32:33 · update #1

13 answers

The parties on religious basis would not have come into existence. inid awould have been peaceful and citizens could have lived in harmony and peace .

2006-09-13 03:44:16 · answer #1 · answered by Infinity 7 · 0 1

You have to know the history. What was the situation before partition.Did they all lived happily and in harmony as bhai bhai?.The point is Muslims were conquerers and British Raj usurped the power from them. So,the British created a Hindu-Muslim divide in order to establish their rule. This eventually culminated in to organisations like VHP, RSS, Muslim league etc with their covert support. Thus a strong Hindu-Muslim hatred was well planted and was going on for almost 100 years.When the time came for the British to quit India,naturally the upper caste Hindu leaders did not want to share their power with Muslims and the best option was to create a seperate state for them which eventually became Pakistan.

It was a power struggle between the Hindu and Muslim elites.The Hindu elite was more than happy to get rid of them. This is the reason why Jinnah could handle the Pakistan negotiations almost single handedly without any great demand or struggle from the Muslim masses.

It was ineveitable. Otherwise Muslims would have crossed 40% combined and it would have been a disaster to live with a full blown live Pakistan inside India.Thank God we made the partition.Otherwise,these guys would have contaminated everyone and we would have gone to pieces.

The best way forward is to live as peaceful,happy neighbours.

2006-09-13 04:40:04 · answer #2 · answered by indiananytime 2 · 0 0

RSS was there even before India became independent. Those were the days of freedom struggle and Rss had its own Maratha flag which they used to plant against injunctions from British rulers. Any one could become member of RSS but except Hindu others who were more pro British desisted from joining the sangh.
It was strongly opposed to partition but our power hungry leaders gave in to Jinnah.
VHP and Bajrang dal came because of the anti Hindu policies of the congress government. Even today congress is trying for Muslim appeasement by fighting the Allahabad high court judgement on stopping the haj subsidy.
Why dont the Muslims refuse the subsidy if they accept all religions are equal under the constitution?
If parties like congress do not encourage religious and political and caste divide for splitting the formation of any opposition India would have advanced without any difficulty. Even Muslims do not realise that it is the neglect of congress which has kept them backward and not because of ordinary Hindu who believes in co-existence and brother hood of man.
From where did they get the word VASUDEVA KUTUMBAKAM?
IT IS ON ACCOUNT OF THE CONGRESS LEADERS LIKE NEHRU THE partition HAPPENED .do not try to alter the history as they are doing it today.

2006-09-13 04:20:43 · answer #3 · answered by Brahmanda 7 · 1 0

Nothing would have been happen if there not been partition because RSS,VHP,Bajrangdal is not a political paties although RSS is a community developer group and VHP and Bajrangdal is a religious party. where as the muslim league is tge political party known for the partition. but if the partition would not happen then also these parties remain for their religious conduct and development and for the Dungas.

2006-09-15 23:08:59 · answer #4 · answered by Ganesh Thakur 2 · 0 0

Well, RSS, VHP, Bajrang dal would have been busy with social activities like now and also work for upliftment of hindu society, like eradication of caste and inculcation of cultural values.

Not sure of muslim league though.

2006-09-13 03:51:54 · answer #5 · answered by Sameer from Hyderabad 2 · 0 0

The RSS has been in existence even before partition and added fuel to Muslim league's demand of partition. No leader of the RSS fought for the freedom and never ever they hoisted national flag on thier head qurters, nor they ever respected the national anthem.[Only 4 years back they have started now]
Thier sister concerns i.e. b'dal, vhp have been involved in destroying the national property duriing thier every agitation and thus wounding the Bharatmata.They have been involved in many conspiracies to spread hatred amongst the two communities.Several follwers have been cought red handed in the antinational activities like throwing MEET in the tamples.

They have been able to convince the innocent Hindus[ very few though],
that it is bcoz of the muslim appeasement that they are aggreived.
One of the particepants has written about the Haj subsidy which the Govt provide to the muslims.Perhaps he doesnt know that there are several state govts, which make provisions of crores of Rs for the temples in Orrissa, Tamilnadu etc.
If somebody ask a question about the muslim appeasement I have plenty of evidences as to who is being appeased. Certainly not the muslims.
Sorry i didnt answer your question till now.

The RSS would not have vanished for the VERY SIMPLE REASON that they are alive ony on muslim backlashing and muslim league would have gone to hell as the Indian muslims love to vote thier hindu leaders.

2006-09-13 05:02:17 · answer #6 · answered by ♪¢αpη' ε∂ïß♪ ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ 6 · 0 2

The purpose of these outfits - be it RSS or Al queda or whatever, is to establish their religious rule in general. As regards RSS, they want their India back like it was 300 years ago with the beautiful caste system and slavery. That is all about the Great VASUDEVA KUTUMBAM wherein not only the unfortunate indian aborigins should always be slaves of an elite class, but having a wild dream like the entire human race should also be enslaved.

2006-09-13 06:31:12 · answer #7 · answered by bala g 2 · 0 1

Partition or no partition wouldn't matter these organisations. Their main motive and ideology is only to look upon other religion and show them down. The situation would have been still same or rather be more worse(complex) as the portions of Muslim would be more as compared to now. The rows that keep coming up every month involving these organisations would have been more frequent.

2006-09-13 04:05:22 · answer #8 · answered by swajji 1 · 0 0

Jerusalem is the 0.33 maximum holiest website in Islam and so which you would be able to comprehend the unhappiness of no longer in basic terms the Palestinians yet in addition from muslims international, rather because of the fact the human beings who the land belongs to are dying of their homes, no longer being allowed to bypass to artwork on their land and being stolen of their produce and are suffering in refugee camps. 'isreal' says the land became into promised to them- I mean, are they having a chortle- if all human beings mentioned that, what may be left of the earth??? yet you comprehend they are asserting, the reality would be triumphant, and then justice would be carried out God keen and each oppressor will sooner or later meet its end. This difficulty isn't one in basic terms for muslims, yet for the completed of humanity, as killing harmless civilians for over 60 years for their very own land can by no ability be morality surprising.

2016-12-12 07:41:14 · answer #9 · answered by ? 4 · 0 0

Muslim league would be the ruling party.RSS etc would ceased to exist.Condition of hidus would be the same as that of Bangladesh now.

2006-09-15 04:51:57 · answer #10 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

They would have merged and formed a Political Party by the name of RSSVHPBDML Secular Party.

2006-09-16 21:02:06 · answer #11 · answered by rajendran 2 · 0 0

fedest.com, questions and answers