Should we return the Elgin Marbles to Greece?

Answer 1

No you can keep them and shove them wherever they suit you best (contact me for some helpful suggestions). One should pity the nations that cannot produce their own culture but have to steal from others...

Answer 2

This suggestions-set that the Greeks do no longer take care of their artifacts is previous and extremely pathetic. Even 2 an prolonged time in the past, the respond could surely be Britain, yet Greece has modernized and has various the perfect museums interior the international. The marbles does not return to the Parthenon, they could be placed in the Acropolis Museum, which already has place settings waiting for them. Greece is totally able to holding and conserving the 'Elgin' marbles, the two in a position with the aid of fact the British Museum. subsequently the marbles ought to in actuality return to Greece as they have been illegally obtained. it rather is not a remember of all artifacts ought to return to the situation of beginning, with the aid of fact frequently they're obtained with the help of purchase or commerce. those weren't. Britain replaced into no longer the colonial capacity in Greece, Turkey replaced into. The Turks gave them to Elgin with the aid of fact they have been battling the Greeks on the time. it may be like the British stealing the assertion of Indepdence with the aid of fact the U.S. replaced into no longer a sovereign us of a on the time. marguerite, it rather is not an 'assumption.' Elgin smuggled them out of Greece after paying off some Ottoman guards. It replaced into no longer a criminal transaction between 2 states. and people keep mis-know-how that the Ottomans have been mistreating the artifacts, no longer the Greeks. no person denies that Elgin did what he concept replaced into perfect, and probable replaced into the perfect element on the time. this isn't the argument.

Answer 3

Just ask what the Greeks think about it? Imagine that someone takes something yours away from you... Would you be happy?

I think the Elgin Marbles should be return to where they belong... In the Parthenon. I have been there and I think the Parthenon looks odd without them... I think they should be put back there...

Is like everything else... Is a national treasure for the Greek people!!

I think we have now seen enough of them here.... Some many years in the British Museum... I guess is now time to send them back where they can also be seen....

Answer 4

Yes, I think the UK government should return them to Greece as a gesture of goodwill and support of modern Greece's effort to protect its remaining monuments.
Whatever the circumstances of their purchase from the Ottoman authorities and their possible fate at that time if they had not been removed, I think the important thing now is to be sympathetic to this reasonable request and return them without any further delay or fuss.
Both nations' people and governments would benefit, if you think about it; not least Britain's for showing the initial removal of the frescoes was not necessarily a greedy act of imperialism.

Answer 5

Yes since lord elgin stole them I think the only decent thing is to hand them back to Greece

Answer 6

Are artworks best as the possesions of nations or those who appreciate them most? But the public good is best shared if art is shared in a manner where the most people can see it. National pride aside, I think the marbles would be best used by being in Greece.

Answer 7

i think you really should return them. as for whoever wrote that 'they're what makes britain great", i suggest you read some history. the british people have a large cultural heritage, numerous precious artifacts of their own, but the Elgin marbles are not their property.

Answer 8

Yes, I think we should now. So they can be enjoyed and rediscover again in the museum there.

I am sure the intentions of Elgin were good at the time but now we are living in a different world.

Answer 9

Hm. Good question. Would the mass looting of irreplaceable historical artefacts following the fall of Saddam Hussein been better off if they had been spread across the world? Not to suggest they wouldnt be safe back in Greece - but perhaps relics of unprecedented historical value should be shared across the world to reduce the risk of losing them if kept in one place?

Answer 10

what are the people in Elgin gonna play with if the do get returned?

Answer 11

They were not bought fair and square. Lord Elgin pinched them and they should be returned forthwith. They are stolen goods and the United Kingdom has no right to them.