Can I ask a fellow student for a grad school letter of recommendation?

Question

I was a journalism major and I often did work as a television reporter, can I ask the student who was my photog. to write me a letter of recommendation. The student has since graduated and works in another field but she can attest to my work ability and she worked hands on with me so she would know if I would be able to complete a graduate program in journalism. Is doing that a big NO-NO.

Answer 1

Good lord, don't even think about it.

Letters from professors are the only ones that will be taken seriously.

The one exception to this rule is if you are currently interning or working in a journalistic capacity; in this case, your managing editor could write a letter.

Answer 2

I'm sure that your grad school will more than likely prefer a letter of recommendation from someone who is your superior and someone you have worked with for a good amount of time. Why not ask your journalism instructor, or your journalism supervisor?

Answer 3

Hello,

I have reviewed many applications and phoned professors who have been listed as a reference. At least 25% of the time the professor takes the attitude of an impartial observer saying as little as possible about the student. In addition, if they are asked any questions, it is very obvious they are taking a very measured and cautious approach in replying. I have always had a negative impression of this type of professor and do not associate their manner with the student. But others who talk to this same type of professor may not be so discriminating. Cultivate some community leaders or professionals in your area of study. They are usually very generous in their opinion. Close friends as references always go way overboard in their praise but they are usually believable if they corroborate what the others have said.

Answer 4

First--is it fairly previous due? Is the college offering you with a cut-off date they want it by making use of? you apart from mght ought to ask somebody (like yet another professor or somebody in the graduate college admissions place of work) how long it many times takes for a professor to place in writing a letter. If this is previous due, attempt some thing alongside the traces of: "hi, I basically heard from my grad college that the advice letter you despatched them on my behalf hasn't been gained yet. Is it available that they lost it or that it became into misaddressed? ought to you please examine your information and enable me be attentive to whilst and to whom it became into despatched? i will attempt and song it down at Grad U. thank you ."

Answer 5

I wouldn't recommend it, they should come from instructor or people that you worked under at the time of your schooling.

Answer 6

I wouldn't do it. Those letters can make or break your admissions chances. Stick to your professors.

Answer 7

If you do, have her sign it with her current credentials and where she works now. It's really best to get it from people who are above you career wise.

Answer 8

You can ask me(-;