Do antidepressants cause more harm than good?

Answer 1

I think so. They are so readily prescribed nowadays. Why not try diet, exercise and counseling first? Seems docs just hand out pills like they are pez.

Answer 2

For some people. I was a couselor for years, and I'll tell you what does more harm than good it is the Deprtment of Social Services. There are negative side effects to some anti- depressants for some people, but if you have seen how much they help some people and their families you would not be asking. I was a Christian Councilor counseling Christians and I ran into this do not use drugs a lot. It is bad thinking The scripture say apply oil, and oil at that time was medicine not a vehicle for annointing. That came later when the translator got it wrong.

Answer 3

I really doubt that they can, antidepressants are not that strong of a medicine and they are not quick acting, people who say
"I haven't taken my Prozac today" are just using this a an excuse to act out. With any thing else they need to continue on them as the Doctor ordered, follow up with the Doctor's advice, or not take them. In cases where there is a problem you may need a different anti depressant or a different dose. The bottom line is though the pills only help someone who is depressed, it takes more than a pill to cure depression.

Answer 4

I even have been bothered by placed up partum melancholy for the previous one twelve months as quickly as I gave delivery to a touch one boy. i could no longer end thinking approximately how my husband loves him greater desirable than me and how issues must be greater appropriate if he wasn't born in any respect. as a effect, I stayed far off from him because of the fact I knew that i might do something i visit remorseful approximately for something of my existence. extraordinarily much promptly I went to a therapist and convince them that i want help. between different issues, i've got tried organic supplementations and different e book to handle melancholy yet no longer something works like the melancholy loose technique. So now i'm proud to assert i'm between the happiest mom contained in the international. My husband loves us the two very lots and that i thank the Lord for the blessing he gave us. melancholy loose technique?

Answer 5

it honestly depends.

it may take one or two different trials of different meds before you find the right one for you... you may get lucky and nail it the first time.

i was not so lucky - discovering my depression in college, was dysthymia (constant low depression), seasonal-affective disordewr (fall/winter/rainy days affect my mood) and serotonin imbalance. i tried herbal remedies first - st. john's wort...after awhile, it had no effect, and i felt like i was declining mentally and emotionally...it was damn scary. so i sought a psychiatrist, and found out that Zoloft is a no-no for me, personally. it gave me nausea, bad body shakes, mood downs, i even had a suicidal event i was fortunate enough to have my friend jim there, he stopped me. i felt like a zombie - apathetic and still very much depressed and scared. needless to say, i weened myself off and sought new help.

my second doctor was very nice, and she prescribed wellbutrin. it worked for a looooong while, in conjunction with counseling sessions, and still keeps me somewhat stable today, though i still have mood changes and slight shakes, they are much more bearable than where i used to be.

these are my shortened versions of honest experiences.

everyone is different. when you find a medicine that works, has minimal-to-no side effects, and you see a counselor/therapist, as well as meetings with a psychiatrist to monitor your meds, the whole package works together OVER TIME to help you. meds are not a strict, immediate cure, but they may help alleviate some of the worst symptoms, or at least minizmie them and make them manageable.

Answer 6

No, they are life savers for millions of people who take the time to talk to their doctors, get one that works for them and take them exactly like they are prescribed. They are NOT addictive but should not be stopped suddenly due to side effects. They also don't work for people who only take them for a short time. It takes at least 4 weeks for them to really work properly and they usually are prescribed for at least 6 months for best effects. They do not all work for everyone because brain chemistry is not the same in every person.

Answer 7

My personal opinion, they do more harm. I was on prozac for a while, and felt very neutral the whole time I was on it, I decided I didn't like that, and went off it. I got more depressed then than I had ever been before taking it. I contemplated suicide for the first time coming down off of prozac... Thank GOD I don't have that crap in me anymore. I've learned that happiness is an inside job.

Answer 8

I don't think so. I know lots of people (including myself) who take them and everyday I tackle another day because of the help they give me. Without them, the chemical imbalance would cause social anxiety and panic attacks.

Answer 9

its possible
one of the known side effects of antidepressants, is suicidal behavior

Answer 10

if used properly and with conjunction with therapy definitely more good but the flip side is people get addicted to anti-depressants and are completely psychotic when not on them. I guess its a catch-22 situation