JAZZ ENTHUSIASTS ONLY PLEASE. In your opinion how would you rate the following Jazz Pianist's.and why.?

Question

One to ten.
Keith Jarrett, Michelle Petruciani, George Shearing, Oscar Peterson, Brian Kellough, Fats Waller, Bill Evans, Erroll Garner, Art Tatum, and Victor Feldman

Answer 1

I've never thought about rating, I don't think I can. I know who I enjoy, but I don't think of comparing.

Here's what I think of when you mention these pianists...
Keith Jarrett-I really enjoy the duet with Charlie Haden on Haden's Closeness album.
Oscar Peterson-Great playing on the Night Train and Trio + 1 albums.
Bill Evans-Undercurrent with Jim Hall is really interesting playing.
Victor Feldman-I love his playing on Cannonball's Live at the Lighthouse album.

I'm not to familiar with the rest of the guys. So I don't have a comment about them.

PS-Horace Silver, Wynton Kelly and Bobby Timmons are some of my old favorites. Aaron Goldberg and Robert Glasper are some of my current favorite players.