Who to start? McNabb or Bledsoe?

Question

I use to have Steve McNair and Drew Bledsoe, but I traded Kevin Jones and McNair for Donovan McNabb.

So, should I start McNabb or Bledsoe?

For those saying it was a bad trade, for my RB's, I have Tiki and Westbrook starting. I still have Frank Gore and Mike Bell on the bench.

Answer 1

mcnabb lost like everyone, all he has is stallworth, who's kind of an underachiever

bledsoe has TO and terry glenn, and jason witten's one of the league's best tight ends

So even though mcnabb's the better QB, he doesnt have many good options so bledsoe will probably do better statistically this season.

Start bledsoe, unless you see mcnabb is taking on a really crappy defense like the 49ers or something.

Answer 2

Why would you trade away a top RB for a QB? I would start McNabb against the Texans...he's out to prove something.

Westbrook has had a nagging injury for most of the preseason...Tiki barber is very good...but he's getting old (in sports years), but should still be able to squeeze out a year or two, Frank Gore might be ok, but unsure of his durability for the entire season at 5'9".

Tiki and Jones should have been the ones you should have kept at the least, in FF you need 2 quality RB's with 2 more back ups for bye weeks and injuries and such.

McNabb is an excellent QB who has proven in the past that he's able to get by without superstar Receivers ( stats from 2000 and 2001 seasons). I think you should have kept Jones and started Bledsoe...now you've created the problem of who to start at QB since you can't start both.

Answer 3

I think McNabb is more solid at least for week 1. Bledsoe and TO haven't had much time to click yet in preseason or even practice and McNabb has been looking great so far this year.

Answer 4

Bad trade, my man. Now that you are saddled with it, you must start the one you traded for. McNabb is as good of a passer and a better scrambler than Bledsoe. I hope you are fat at the RB position.

No offense, but try running your trades by us before you make them. It's good to get an objective view. Hey, I've made a few bad ones myself.

Good luck.

Answer 5

Mcnabb

Answer 6

Kurt Warner. however the undeniable fact which you have Brett Favre in this record is stupid. he's no longer the rationalization is group isn't helpful he's doing as much as he can and if he grew to become into on a competent group he can cause them to extra effective. Sgoldperson is sweet. You human beings are loopy. Ben has one undesirable season and you think of he's the worst he did extra in his first 2 years then GOD ALMIGHTY Phillip Rivers who SAT THE BENCH, and ELI MANNING. He took a set to the convention champ his rookie 3 hundred and sixty 5 days and u understand all he did in his Sophomore 3 hundred and sixty 5 days grew to become into in user-friendly terms a super bowl identify no longer something particular u human beings are insane. i've got in no way heard Plummer referred to as the subsequent Elway. Bledsoe hasn't been something on condition that he left New England. Brooks in no way grew to become into. McNabb have been given harm what the hell do u anticipate him to do.

Answer 7

Ummm thats a toughy man..I would start Bledsoe the 1st week tho. T.O. and Glenn are big targets for him and if the O -line keeps Bledsoe of his back he should be great...but after the first week start whoever has my fantasy points. Hope i could help.

Answer 8

I think you made a bad trade but I would start McNabb

Answer 9

thats a tough one, bledsoe has t o , but mcnabb has been hot this preseason, and has picked up some weapons, but there is a bit of a qb contraversy in dallas id go with donavon!

Answer 10

I think McNabb because he not only can pass the ball, but he himself moves alot faster and more for the score!