can uo answer the following questions before forcing anybody to sing it ?
1.Is there any national song in the world which does not have the name of the nation like
vande matram ?
2.How many of you who want it to be sung by everybody, can sing it without any help ?
3.How many of the persons who can sing it, can tell the meaning of the song ?
4.When only few hundred out of the total population in India can sing it with meaning then
who are you to force the others to sing it ?
5.Whether the song was written for a novel or for the nation ? Whether the motive of the
auther was to glorify his nation or novel ?
6.Who the auther was seving when he wrote the song ?
7.Are the clerics on the higher level not required to just clarify that vande matram does not mean doing PUJA of the motherland but it simply means to glorify and to give respect to your motherland ?
Even after this if the muslims dont sing they are liable to be punished
2006-09-02 22:07:55 · 7 answers · asked by ♪¢αpη' ε∂ïß♪ ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ 6 in Politics & Government ➔ Politics
Vande Matram was sung to unite the freedom strugglers,to motivate them.No I don't know about other nation' s song Iam NOT INTERESTED .I love my nation and all the things assosiated with it irrespective of caste creed and colourYou know "Sare jahan se " was given by Iqbal .So hindus have accepted it.Why? because its related to our national strugglenot because it has "hind"in it I think these things of freedom struggle should be known by everyone.Atleast respect them and try to learn them .A life of 60 years is enough to learn vande matram
2 Yes I can sing it I learn it myself as I love my nation
Vande Matram ! Vande Matram!
Vande Matram! Vande Matram!
Sujlum shuflum malayag sheetlam
Sasya shyamlam matram vande matram
vande matram 3
Shubhra jyotishna pulkit yamini
phull kusumit drumadal shobhini
suhashini sumudhar bhasini
sukdha varda matram
vande matram 3...
3 I know its meaning
4 There is no one to force these people who divide our country on the basis of caste .It simply means They don't love India
5 The song was written for novel but later it became the symbol of freedom struggle and patriotism
6 Its not a puja to the the nation but respect and love to her to glorify her but isn't it enough to sing it?
Muslims should not be punished but I am shocked that Muslim are too caste consicious I want to know why they relate everything as an insult to their caste .Is their religion so fake that singing a Vande Matram will hurt their religious sentiment.?
2006-09-02 22:50:32 · answer #1 · answered by riya k 2 · 0⤊ 0⤋
Gentleman, it is not a question, whether muslim brethren will sing or not. Should I remind you that this song has inspired freedom fighters to collectively fight for the motherland.How can you so easily forget their sacrifices. You are living in a free country because of them.
The concept of treating one's country as motherland (Matrubhumi) is unique to India only ( respect the country as you respect your mother).What is wrong in it. Will it be fair to consider our country to be Matrabhumi(only land-lifeless,an inanimate object).The song does not compell any one to leave his /her faith but only glorifies the nation, developing selfrespect for the nation. It is only if you feel great , you can do great deeds. Do you mean to say that some people should be allowed not to respect the nation.
The object of writing a book is not entertainment only, but to provide an insight of the society . Every story has a moral. Love ur nation is what Bankim Da has told through his song and book.
2006-09-02 22:36:07 · answer #2 · answered by prakash s 3 · 0⤊ 0⤋
Upper Ridge Road was renamed as Vande Mataram Marg). It is surrounded by Rajinder Nagar on western side, Karol bagh on northern side and Birla Mandir on the eastern side. Budh Jayanthi Park is on Vande Mataram Marg (or road).
2016-03-27 05:10:55 · answer #3 · answered by Anonymous · 0⤊ 0⤋
vande mataram has meanings which glorifies the motherland.if u study the meanings of its each and every word then it has meanings like "i offer my soul to u my mother land and i offer myself at ur feet.
according to its meanings it gives utmost importance to the land more than GOD.according to islamic beliefs,muslims believe that there is nothing more great than the almighty god,,,who has created this wonderful world for us.so we should surrender ourself to god rather than the land in which we live..
and mind u no one can force anybody to sing vande mataram,coz its not a national anthem..
2006-09-03 01:49:10 · answer #4 · answered by Anonymous · 0⤊ 0⤋
Listen wot Bin laadin has to say:P India is a multicultural and secular country and every Indian including bin laadin loves our nation and expresses it in a different way as every one sings saare jahaan say acchha hidostaan humaara y not sing along in saral bhasha y go to sankrut a least spoken language
all these political gimmiks r bull sh*t dont bother and keep loving INDIA its a best place to live n die for:)
2006-09-03 00:00:00 · answer #5 · answered by ♥bin ladin♥ 2 · 0⤊ 0⤋
It can be sung by every one without being made conditional to make it compulsory. Why infringe on some one's right and decide for him? After all we live in a civilized society and not in a country ruled by the power of sword
2006-09-02 22:26:29 · answer #6 · answered by Naresh C 3 · 0⤊ 0⤋
we have to learn vande mataram. to love mother land is good sign to our country. only few people oppose this patriotic song .
2006-09-02 23:29:36 · answer #7 · answered by prithvi 3 · 0⤊ 0⤋