Who had it worse?

Question

African Americans in slavery times, Jews during the Holocaust, or American Indians when they were being kicked off of their land. Why?

Answer 1

See the Jews where oppress for 13 years killing 6 million people by one man and his army. But Germany paid Jews over 700 million in repartition's. That a huge amount of people kill in such a short period of time.

But Blacks was a different story Black were to be slaves not to be kill they were worth $20,000 plus. With that being said according to "The ***** in our History" it is estimated that the Black race had no less than 50,000,000 people die during the middle passage alone. And many more of the 11/12 million who made it alive died within weeks of arrival to the New World. Only God know how many millions were killed unjustified over the coarse of 400 years.

But that not the problem not only were they in a foreign land with nations that hated them they also lost their religion, nationity, culture and customs and their way of life thing that no money can repalce. These people live a life where they worried day and night, like were did their children go, is my husband ok, when will we get home. Many case even in the 1950's black said they would rather be died and buried in their grave before they be oppressed. But after all of this, 400 years have went in vain no other race on the face of the Earth at anytime could say they had it worst than blacks.

As far as Indians I don't know, but probably lest than Jews and Blacks. Nothing Indain went through that black didn't. The difference between Indians and Blacks is that Indains are ok with it.

Answer 2

Wow. that's a toughie. I'd have to go wtih the American Indians. Althought the other two groups were extremely mistreated, the american indians were also mistreated but in pretty much every single way possible. Slavery was more about money, holocaust was about an age old anti-semitic farce steeped in christian lore. Anything religious in my opinion is a farce all unto itself. It so happened that the jews got the sh*it end of the stick in this situation.

The american indians were initally peaceful, welcomed the white man and even sat down with them for dinner. this is not the act of a barbaric society nor one of malcontent. with the new trust the "americans" garnered, they exploited and betrayed that trust for everyh single imaginable reason. they promised no harm during their westward expansion, they promised nice reservations and fair treatment, they promised whatever it was in their treaties as men of their word. Throughout all of this, the indians were merely forced to react to the raping and pillaging of THEIR land, not ours. and by doing so they crafty american swine spin doctored the whole thing into a multitude of bloody wars leading to the ultimate demise of the native american tribes. before our arrival the land was peaceful and there was an equilibrium with nature. when we arrived, we plowed the earth, killed everything that moved (just for their skins) carved roads and essentially destroyed the earth all in the name of manifest destiny.

Bottom line? how many african americans and jews do you see daily? a fair amount correct?
How many native americans do you see (excluding the ones you see on tv or in magazines)??????
I'd have to say not a lot.

Answer 3

The answer to this question is whoever feels that they had it worse. Honestly, to compare the suffering of the three would be as foolish as asking two maimed people, which was worst having your leg chopped off, or having your arm chopped off, because at the end of the day, you are both minus an extremity. Now one could say that you could use your hand more that your feet so the person with the missing arm is worst off. However, each body part is as equally important to each person.

Therefore, whether your people were incinerated, were on the boat ride to hell, or were jacked for their land the fact remains that each were victims of brutality and racism and an extreme number of lives were lost.

I’m a descendant of the people who took the boat ride to hell and I would NEVER compare suffering with other groups for they were all very, very bad.

Answer 4

I imagine this question can only be answered by a meeting of the minds of those you listed. How could I say one of these groups had it worse than the other two, when I didn't go through any of these myself?

Even if such a meeting happened, I'm sure there would be no clear winner or loser as it were on this topic. I like the question though, made me think about just how bad things had been for more than just one group of people

Answer 5

All were horrible. How would like to be forced from your country put into slavery, be beaten and raped? Or would you like it if someone took your family into a gas-chamber and killed all of you. What about someone came to your land and killed your family, burned your houses down or killed all the animals that you once lived with and helped you find food? Answer those questions and see what you come up with.

Answer 6

basically examining those solutions are going to furnish me a nightmare questioning of if those musicians formed a band. Worst Vocalist: Chad Kroeger Worst Drummer: Meg White (in spite of the shown fact that I do basically like the White Stripes) Worst Bassist: Nikki Sixx Worst Guitarist: Herman Lee

Answer 7

Answering this is purely subjective. As far as I'm aware none of us experienced these things and it's impossible to make that call. I'm sure if you asked a slave, a native American and a Jew they would all give compelling reasons for their answers.

Answer 8

I think they all had it really bad. It's kinda morbid to turn it into a contest of who suffered more though, don'tcha think?

Answer 9

You really shouldn't making pole out of this, not only is it disrespectful, it's sick also.

Answer 10

what about circus freaks?

no one ever fights for the circus freak.