Do you think that Ryan Star should have been the next one to go on Rockstar: Supernova??

Answer 1

Ryan should have been in part of the final three contestants for the season finale. The person who should have gone before him is Storm, for not being able to adapt her voice properly to certain songs. Second behind her should have been Lucas, who deserved to be removed from the show because his forced gravel voice makes every song sound the same. Finally, and for this I know I will get a lot of flack, but I think Dilana should go because ultimately she does not have the integrity and emotional resilience to be part of a group that is constantly in the public eye, as demonstrated by the behind the scenes episodes.

Ryan’s song writing talent, his arrangement style, and the gamut of his voice at least give him enough credibility to be in the final three. Ultimately his serious physical presence conflicts with Supernova’s more upbeat disposition, and he would be eliminated inevitably. I just think it is sad that they couldn’t retain him on the show a little longer than the other less deserving souls.

Answer 2

I thought Storm did the best performance tonight.

I am so sad to see Ryan go. I thought Storm would go before Ryan and I wonder how much it came down to a numbers game, with only two left in the competition.

Ryan was woeful tonight but so was Dilana. I loved it when everyone booed when the first bottom 4 were announced and when Dilana was announced there was a small boo but mainly a lot of clapping. She needed a reality check.

Loved Magni not being in the bottom at all tonight. I was afraid that if he hit the bottom for a third week in a row, he would be out.

I'm a bit bewildered about why you would get rid of the guy who has "grown the most in this competition" over the girl who "has shown the least growth". Then again, I don't know how Storm can grow when I think she's been brilliant from Day 1.

Last night's performance was the best night of competition to date in my view.

Howeverl, I'm having more cringe moments in this series than the last; the other week when Dave told Magni he should have thrown the guitar and the very next song Ryan did it ... last night when SN said to Magni he should have gone up the back and Toby went and did that tonight. It seems they are losing their originality.

I guess next week's songwriting challenge might sort the rest of them out.

I get the feeling that Jason doesn't agree with the other two on who should front the band. He didn't seem at all impressed with Ryan leaving tonight over, I think, Dilana. I don't think Jason is a fan of hers at all.

Answer 3

I was a little surprised he left over Storm, even though I loved her performance. I don't think he was right for Supernova. He'll do great as a solo act, he doesn't need Supernova. The only one I can see fronting the band from the show is Dilana. The fact that she was in the bottom three was ridiculous just because of what she said. It should all be based on performance, not what so-n-so said about so-n-so. Honestly the further we get into the show the more I think the best lead isn't there.

Answer 4

No i felt Dilana or Storm should have gone. He's the "most evolved" (outta tommy lee's mouth) and shown the most growth but yet he gets the boot. And Dilana turns into a psycho and stays.....pffft

Answer 5

You've got the WORST taste in music and would have the WORST taste in entertainment if you liked talentless reality shows! Listen to good music like ICP!

Answer 6

No I think Storm should have went last night

Answer 7

no.... I think dilana should go cause she's a back-stabber b****

Answer 8

no, he's great dude.