Why do doctors and dentists say things as if they are God-"If you don't do this then that will happen, you

Question

have three weeks to live, if you don't do this procedure, your teeth will fall out before the year is over, etc. etc. etc." My mom was given three years and it's been twenty and she's still fine-all the doctor gave us was stress. Dentist told my brother his tooth would fall out by the time he was 23. He's 50 and still has it. And I could go on and on and on with examples and I'm sure you have them too-but if these so-called health care workers really cared about our health they would never say such things-they don't know because they aren't Gods AND they only exaccerbate the problem by adding tremendous stress. So, what are your thoughts and do you have doctor/dentist stories to share?

Answer 1

Doctors get money for performing their job, so of course they want you to be a good customer and come back often. They get a cut if they refer you to someone they know, and put their kids through school with the money they attain from frivolous operations and procedures. Why does the grocery store tell you to buy more stuff? They told me I would surely have to have open heart surgery by the time I was 15, then 17, then by 25 for sure. Here I am at 29, no heart surgery, and no heart problems. Imagine the problems I would have if I had let them cut me open when I was 15.

Answer 2

while you're given non-emergent scientific suggestion, you may evaluate the challenge and the answer, ask your self in spite of if it particularly is sensible. study the subject. Get a 2nd opinion or save on with-up lab artwork. evaluate the hazards. there's a huge distinction between detrimental a tooth and detrimental a needed organ. If between the hazards for no longer having a technique is a death, a doctor is obligated to make it easier to comprehend of such. Ask a lot of questions, take notes so which you do no longer forget approximately significant suggestion...determine you leave completely reported of the situation. evaluate your beleifs and values, they'll play a place interior the determination you're making. in keeping with risk the scientific experts are no longer bearing directly to themselves as God, yet in keeping with risk you are the single that takes their suggestion as such. it particularly is significant that a affected person is a proactive member of his or her own well being care team. Take some duty on your well being care judgements. training is significant, and suggestion is extensively available (somewhat presently). And, somewhat attainable, if the scientific expert's "bedside way" does not artwork for you, try switching medical doctors. There are some human beings who prefer a scientific expert who's frank and to the factor, jointly as others might pick to be "spoon-fed" suggestion in a comfortable way. do no longer somewhat understand if that solutions your question...yet desire it facilitates.

Answer 3

doctors and dentists (as well as all health providers, including nurses) all are trying to educate their patients. why? because we want our patients to be as healthy and as vital as they can be. we make an effort to give our patients all of the information and education they need about their disease, injury, medications, therapy, and etc. what i think is going wrong in yoru case (where the doctors say "if you dont do this then that will happen") is that these doctors/dentists that youre talking to arent using correct communication. they should not be telling you in those words. they should be more gentle, and they should be direct and give you any bad news or bad prognosis, but should do so in a less threatening way. to me, that way seems rather threatening and as if the doctor/dentistis using scare tactics to get you to do certain things that he wants you to do. the best way to approach it is to give the patient the choice along with the information rather than trying to scare them into making a certain decision. it is good to steer the person and tell them what is in their best interest, but not "if you dont do this then that will happen." its just poor communication.

Answer 4

they have to give you the worst case scenario to cover their ***.

imagine what it'd be like if they said "yeah, you'll live another 20 years" and she died in less than 3?.