English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

The SA Football Association (Safa) have offered incoming Bafana Bafana coach Carlos Alberto Parreira a R1.8m per month salary. Don't you think this is too much? And if not, what makes him worth all that money? Will he be able to prove his worth in time or can we already assume that this was a mistake?

2006-08-28 22:51:53 · 14 answers · asked by Porgie 7 in Travel Africa & Middle East South Africa

14 answers

The salary offered to Parreira is slightly less than he would normally be accustomed to and about half of what top Premiership players in England earn. For the likes of Ferguson,Wenger,Mourinho even Ericcson etc it is spare cash. In South African terms it is a fortune but what you are not seeing is that it is paid by FIFA who "donated" $10 million to your FA to assist in building a team for 2010. So you are a little out of touch with the realities of professional football at the top end. Is he worth it? No if you go on the performances of Brazil in Germany when it was widely accepted that they had the best individual players and only made it to the last 16 with some unimpressive performances. If you go on his record in Saudi Arabia then you will also reach the same conclusion. He is not the answer for SA for the very simple reason that you do not have international class players who can cut it in the major leagues in Europe and neither does he have the time or ability to nurture them. All the other major names touted fell by the wayside and you can safely assume they were never interested and it was merely a publicity stunt for the locals.Your answer lay in Lucas Radebe but in another shambles in your football administration he has walked out of his job as 2010 Ambassador totally disillusioned, back to a coaching position with Leeds Utd. South African football is in a bad way with perhaps only Pienaar,McCarthy and Fortune , who will both be over the hill by 2010 if they are not already there, as your leading lights. So you can assume this was a major mistake and the money would have been better spent on facilities for youngsters to graduate in the game which would have been better for all of South African football in the long term. The other point that comes to mind is that your news reports say that his salary was approved by your Parliament which would put the South African FA in breach of FIFA rules which expressly state the Governments are not allowed to interfere with National Football teams. Greece were recently suspended from all UEFA competitions for precisely this reason and I wonder if FIFA will act against the SA football authorities if it comes to their attention.

2006-08-29 04:27:47 · answer #1 · answered by Anonymous · 4 1

I'm sorry, but R1,8 m IS SO A MISTAKE. I mean hello, everybody is going off about the poverty in SA, the AIDS victims, the crime for PETE'S SAKE!!!!

Do you know what even a month's salary could mean in this country. And by the way who do you think are going to pay for it. At the end of the day, is it you and me my fellow South African friend. Glad to say, it would not affect the South African sitting overseas as much.

But still, what can ONE person do with R1.8m Rand PER MONTH THAT IS!!!!

South Africa's soccer team is not up to what it should be, I mean how can South Africa host the 2010 soccer cup (and don't get me wrong, I am proud of South Africa winning the bid), and we didn't even participate in the past world cup? How does that work.

The 2010 World cup could have mean so much to this country, whether it is for economy, or people to see (like "baldy") that South Africa is a great place, but instead, we give it to some guy, thinking he can save our Bafana Bafana team.

I just think that the money could go for much better things, maybe sending police officers on a course to be better in what they do.

And they say South Africa hasn't got money! TAKE A LOOK AT WHAT OUR BAFANA BAFANA COACH EARN!

2006-08-30 04:24:36 · answer #2 · answered by poepies 4 · 0 0

I don't know what the normal salary ranges of a national coach are, but what I do know is that Clive Barker was just as good as any other international coach, and when he was in France in 1998 coaching Bafana-Bafana in the World Cup, he asked for a salary increase which was still far too lower than R1.8M per month. SAFA refused, and thought he was blackmailing the South African Football Squad. I wonder what has suddenly changed now. As it looks, R1.8M per month is ridiculous. At the present moment I wish more money could be spent in improving the national safety and security.

2006-08-29 01:56:02 · answer #3 · answered by Diezel 4 · 4 1

That is far too much! South Africa should not be worried about Bafana Bafana going to the World Cup because we have other things to worry about! There is a chance that the SPCA might be closing down because they cant afford it anymore but they can however afford to pay R1.8m A MONTH to a new coach! That is rediculous!!! We have poverty in South Africa and people with AIDS and cancer, the LEAST we can do to help is donate these poor people R1 Million a month!

Kim :(

2006-08-29 20:43:36 · answer #4 · answered by Anonymous · 0 1

I agree. It's a sport & shouldn't have anything to do with the colour of the player's skin. It should be about the best players being in the best teams. Afterall, they represent the country in a sport, not as polititions & government officials. If the boks were choosing players based on skin & not skill, why is Habanna, JP Petersen & the Ndungane brothers always part of our best teams. And there are many others like them. It's not to fill a qouta, it's because they are the best at what they do, that's why they're there. Are they now gonna kick Roland Schoeman, Ryk Neethling & Natalie du Toit out the swimming teams to put black swimmers in there too? SA will be the laughing stock of the world when it comes to sport.

2016-03-26 23:52:01 · answer #5 · answered by ? 4 · 0 0

The only way Bafana Bafana is gonna get into the world cup is by hosting it! We are not Brasil and Parreira is gonna find that out really soon! R1.8 is 600grand more than Mbeki makes a YEAR!! Now safa say they expect of him to win the african cup of nations in 2008 and 2010 and atleast get to the third round of the world cup?!! Whatever!!! He wont last till end 2007!!

It's a bloody joke!!

Wie dink hy is hy????

2006-08-29 00:29:08 · answer #6 · answered by Anonymous · 3 1

Hi there Porgie

I think R1.8million per month is ridiculous, especially considering the poverty in SA. Personally I'd much prefer to see SAFA donating R1.5 million / month to good charities and paying some coach R300k / month.
I mean, you'll struggle on R300k / month, but somehow you'll make ends meet? ;)

The guy has lead 4 teams to world cup victory, so that cannot be downplayed.
Dunno, seems like a waste to me?

Cheers

2006-08-28 23:27:00 · answer #7 · answered by AJ 2 · 4 1

it is a rather steep salary. You cant buy passion though, SA soccer "stars" are a bunch of lazy people. They dont have any passion when it comes to playing for SA. You can pay a coach R100 million a month, it doesnt change what the players think or do.

2006-08-29 02:35:11 · answer #8 · answered by tay_jen1 5 · 0 2

well lets think about it...
they can dish out 1.8 mil to a soccer coach, that's team wasn't in the last world cup.
but when it comes to aids orphans, homeless and jobless people, our country has no money....
i think it is definitely too much!

2006-08-29 03:14:00 · answer #9 · answered by Anonymous · 1 0

Hey porg....
Its insane for any1 to earn that much money... But what can we say, this government of ours is so skrewed up at the moment.. lets see how hard they fall if their plan doesnt work, no wait, they not gonna fall, us tax payers are....
dammmmm b-e-people.

2006-08-29 01:22:17 · answer #10 · answered by Hector 3 · 4 1

fedest.com, questions and answers