what's the good punishment for those who commit suicide ?

Question

When somebody commit a suicide , he is a quitter because he was not courageous enough to confront life and its problems so he quits . He puts his family and relatives in trouble : they will cry , be sad , pay for his funerals ...etc while he is somewhere resting in peace or having good times in hell or in heaven or something......
I think we should figure out the way a special way to treat their corpses ; like feed them to sharks or to wild animals or burn them or put them to jail or something . what do you think ? Got a better way ?

Answer 1

The good one is to let GOD decide what to do with them . not men to .

Answer 2

Try some caring and sensitivity before they feel they need to commit suicide. If someone commits suicide it isn't just a failure on their part it can also reflect (sadly) a failure of the people around them to recognize the problem. Still you can't blame the living it is often hard to know how really depressed someone is. You anger is staggering and reflects the feelings of either someone so nasty they don't care about people or someone who is in terrible pain because a loved one has done this. I would bet on the latter and I hope I'm wrong. If I'm right I am so sorry.

Answer 3

Those who commit suicide are frequently deranged in some way. Sometimes they have emotional or mental problems that are genetic. Sometimes they have been in a car accident and have become brain damaged. Sometimes they have caught an infectious disease and are dying a slow, agonizing death and lose their minds. There are lots of disorders beyond people's control that can cause people to kill themselves.

To those Christians who believe hellfire is in store for such people, SHAME ON YOU!!! That is a fate deserved more by the judgemental.

My point is: You need to develop into a real, compassionate human being, not the shallow shell you are, pretending to be one. I doubt there are many 2 dimensional cartoon characters from the Sunday funnies in heaven.

Answer 4

Don't go passing judgement of something you have no way of understanding. Many people commit suicide because they have a chemical inbalance in their brain making them unable to be happy, and people like you treat them like **** because people don't think it's a real disease. Others are dying a slow painful death by some deadly disease. True, some could have had the strength to convince themselves things can change, but in the moment, sometimes you can't control what your mind is telling you. Maybe the people left behind should be punished for not giving a **** about the person until it gets to the point where the only way they know to prove their point is kill themselves.

Answer 5

Yes, I was so angry at someone for sayign F you to all and everybody one time that i wouldn't go to her funeral. It is very self centered. The least you could do is feed them to sharks, but that would hurt the family. You know what I mean?
Also when a counselor comes out with " Everything was fine! I just saw the person!", they are stupid, because being fine and glad after a bout of mental illness is a great indicator that a sick person has made a decision. And a bad one at that. Search google for warning signs. Whoever you are angry at for this, your reaction is very normal and healthy. You are having a normal reaction to an abnormal situation.
I guess,just be glad that you really happen to be blessed with a great outlook on life and you obviously care about your own family enough to understand that they love you. That's probobly why you don't understand the actions that somebody probobly real sick would take.

Answer 6

Isn't 'good punishment' an oxymoron?

You're really pissed off about somebody who left the party early.
Yes, people who take themselves out leave a wake in their path.
Would you be as angry if it had been from an accident or sickness? Grief has many forms and happens to us all, sooner or later.

But I do believe that what men/women do lives after them.
It is called Karma and I truly believe it follows our souls,
wherever we go. Dharma concerns the good things we do,
have learned and I truly believe it follows us too!

There IS a natural balance.
There IS justice.
Whether we can see it, yet, or not.
Good luck.

Answer 7

I'm a bit disturbed by this question. Most people that committ ssuicide are suffering from severe depression, untreated mental illness, drug addiction, or other severe problem. No one just offs themselves for the heck of it. And even if they did, why would society not value their life, and mistreat their corpse?
Its far easier to try to judge and label those who commit suicide than it is to try to understand why it happens. you might do well to do some intense reading on the subject. I wouldnt call them quitters- I would say they committed the most desperate of acts.

Answer 8

I feel sorry that you feel that way about people who commit suicide. They're not evil people for the most part. They are just very sad and very troubled people. I hope that whatever it is they find after death, is someplace that they won't be as sad or as troubled.

I think that God won't punish these people but treat them with the gentleness that they need and possibly didn't get in this life.

Answer 9

Depression is a very complex illness. Suicide is one result of that illness. Some simply can not cope. They have suffered enough. I think I would let this alone if I were you.

Answer 10

My brother commit suicide and I'm very proud of him. You really don't know what problems can be in their minds.
For me I think he save me and still one of the pillars of my life.
I agree with some answer, this question really disturb me.

Answer 11

you have gotten saved you funds. you have offered a lie by using figuring out directly to believe words from a incorrect human as unfavorable to a suited and holy God. devil used the comparable procedures interior the backyard of Eden. He basically asked Eve the question, "Did God say...?" He have been given her to doubt what God had certainly mentioned. on the instant, devil does the comparable subject. He provides us with all kinds of fake tips and then asks, "Did God say...?" If He can get us to doubt God's be conscious, he can get us to believe all kinds of lies. His first and optimal objective is to interfere with the gospel so a individual does not count on Jesus' sacrifice as finished charge for his or her sins. in the event that they pick to believe on Christ particularly of their own solid works, they acquire God's loose present of eternal existence, basically as God has mentioned. as quickly as they have believed, no longer something will substitute their eternal destiny. understanding this, devil then transformations his objective. he will have misplaced this individual to eternal existence, yet he will then attempt to confuse them and get them to doubt what God has mentioned by using offering fake tips. in this way, they in turn will proceed to bypass fake tips directly to others, struggling with others from growing to be to be believers, it is what you're doing. do no longer believe the e book you purchased, and don't even believe me. believe God! return to examining the certainty of the Bible. you heavily isn't taught fact from sinners like that author, me, or the different human; basically from God Almighty. I recommend you study Matthew 35:40 six - "And those will go away into eternal punishment, however the righteous into eternal existence." accompanied by using Luke sixteen:19-31 (paying specific interest to vs. 26; "fastened" meaning under no circumstances to be moved or replaced) God Himself chosen the be conscious "eternal". If He did no longer recommend constantly, He'd have chosen a diverse be conscious like 'non everlasting', no longer "eternal". something different than "eternal" could have been a lie. study God's be conscious and depart the human nonsense to unbelievers.