How do you know when to propose in Harvest Moon: Another Wonderful Life?

Question

I've got 4 hearts with Gustafa and gone through 3 cut scenes. It's currently late fall. Should I wait for the final cut scene first? Do any other conditions have to be right?

Answer 1

you can propose whenever you want. the scenes are nice, but if he doesn't accept, he won't keep the feather, so try as much as you like.

there are a total of four scenes, i believe, for each person, but the fourth is usually hard to come by. at night time, in the fall or the winter, as you leave the inn, scene four would occur. gustafa will head into the bar... and you'll automatically follow him, i think.

Answer 2

you may in user-friendly terms advise to him at a definite time of the twelve months, and all 4 hearts ought to be huge. additionally, you may in user-friendly terms provide Marlin one ingredient an afternoon, so save that throughout innovations. while you're in iciness already, then hurry via fact in case you are not getting all people to settle for the feather in the previous the twelve months's end you will ought to initiate the recreation over.

Answer 3

just give him the blue feather i think. the site below is a marriage guide for the game.