Pink Floyd The Wall Question?

Question

If you listen carefully to the beginning of The Wall, I think it is Roger Waters says something. It is very difficult to hear, but I think he is asking a question. The very end of The Wall he answers that question but again it is very difficult to hear. You have to listen very carefully to the first and last second of the album because it is very easy to miss. I doubt most Floyd fans ever even noticed because it is so subtle. Does anyone know what he is saying? thanks

Answer 1

He is saying "you can't have your pudding if you don't eat your meat,how can you have any pudding if you don't eat your meat?"

Answer 2

At he beginning of In the Flesh he says "We came in?". At the end of Outside the wall he says "isn't there?". If you join both it says Isn't there we came in?. I heard that it means that the wall (crisis, isolation, etc) is a cycle from a generation to the next one.

Answer 3

According to the The Wall album's lyrics, the first thing he says is "....we came in?" The last thing he says at the end of the album is "Isn't this where...."

http://www.pink-floyd-lyrics.net/pink-floyd-lyrics/thewall.htm

Answer 4

At the beginning he says "we came in?"

At the end he says "Isn't this where..."

Put the tracks in a loop and what do you get?

Roger has a fascination with cycles, if you haven't noticed.

Answer 5

i've noticed it on the movie, but i've never paid much attention to it. now that you've said something, i want to go watch the movie again witht the volume on full blast to try to figure it out.

Answer 6

It sonds to me like it "...when we came in" but, it also sounds as if part of what he is saying was cut off. And again, at the end it sounds cut off. Sonds to me like, "...so this where"

Answer 7

I have the cd, i will listen to it tonight and i will get back to you tomorrow.

Answer 8

no