which one of these five is the best closer in baseball, today ?

Question

Trevor Hoffman
Jonathan Papelbon
Mariano Rivera
B.J. Ryan
Billy Wagner

...Or is there any other pitcher who you believe to be the best closer in baseball, today.

Answer 1

no one better than rivera

Answer 2

Mariano Rivera. It's hard for me to say it, I hate the Yankees. He's the most consistent over the years. It's wayyyyy too soon in Papelbon's career to even put him in the same sentence as some of the others. Wagner and Hoffman are consistent as well. Others like Huston Street... It's too early to tell. Look at Todd Jones. Rolaids reliever of the year in 2000 I think it was, then gets a middle relief role for 5 years until G Mota of the Marlins blows out his arm. Now look at the consistency and numbers he's put up.

Bottom line. CLOSERS ARE A DIME A DOZEN. Anyone can do it. Come into a game in the bottom of 9 with a 3 run lead, get three outs and you get a save. The only catch is you have to get those three outs every time. What ever happened to Derrick Turnbow?

Answer 3

Mariano Rivera

Answer 4

Mariano Rivera

Answer 5

1 Yankees Mariano Rivera
2 Red Sox Jonathan Papelbon
3 Twins Joe Nathan
4 Blue Jays BJ Ryan
5 Angels Frankie Rodriguez

Billy Wagner gives too many heart palpatations, i have yet to see him come into a game this year for the mets and retire the side 1,2,3 ..every damn save he gets he puts the tieing, or go ahead/winning run on base, and i dont think he's doing it on purpose to make things interesting

Trevor Hoffman has never seen a huge save he couldnt figure out a way to blow.. all you haveta do is look up his save percentage in Playoffs and Meaningful games... the Home run ball Scott Brosius hit off of him in 1998 to give the Yankees the lead in San Diego in that World Series game still hasnt come down. And his Choking isnt limited to the playoffs.. i watched him in a interleague game that the Padres were up 4-2 in the bottom of the ninth in yankee stadium, he comes in and proceeds to give up a home run to Hideki Matsui (ok fine, Matsui is a power hitter),, games 4-3 now, then he finds that wasnt bad enough, so he gives up the tieing home run to the very next hitter Kenny Lofton, who isnt exactly known for his power stroke LOL.

As for Bobby Jenks... You stick him out there if you want to against David Ortiz and Manny Ramirez of Boston..or Damon, Jeter, Abreu, Giambi, Arod, of the Yankees Throwing that 99mph STRAIGHT AS A PIN fastball he has, in a 1 run game, and we'll see how long it takes before he's rubbing up a new ball cause the last got deposited in outfield seats. LOL

Also, the problem with saying ANYONE can Close games "Closers are a dime a dozen". is that, if EVERYONE could do it, why are there SO few good ones in the game? for every Rivera, Papelbon, Nathan, Ryan, Rodriguez, Street.... You have a dozen Billy Koch's, Derick Turnbows, Danny Kolbs, Arthur Rhodes, Octavio Dotells, Brad Lidges, Tom Gordon's, Guillermo Motas, Kyle Farnesworths, etc... Who have GREATstuff, but have shown they couldnt get those last 3 out in a game in a huge pressure situation if their lives depended on it.

Answer 6

There are a lot of closers in today's game who are very good. There are very few who are absolutely lights-out in the 9th inning. Papelbon of the Red Sox is lights-out, whereas Ryan, Wagner, and Hoffman are both very good. I think Mariano Rivera is, in my mind, the best closer in the game. He is one of the most intimidating presences in the game, mainly because he's been so good for so long. The other guys I'd consider to be the best are Francisco Rodriguez of Anaheim and Bobby Jenks of the White Sox.

Answer 7

Rivera. He's been great for 10 years. If I had to win one game to save my life, I'd want Mariano to pitch the ninth inning. Best closer ever.

Bobby Jenks should be on your list. He closed out the World Series last year, and he is 36-for-38 in save opportunities this year. I'd take him ahead of Papelbon, regardless of what the ESPN dorks think.

Answer 8

Papelbon looks pretty impressive, striking out batters at will... and Billy Wagner is very good but unpredictable (and I am a Mets fan), but the best closer that if I were a manager I'd put my money on is Mariano... he blows it once in a while but he's still the undisputed champion

Answer 9

Like others have said, if you have the game on the line you're going to put the ball in Rivera's hands.

However, Papelbon is the only one on the list with a legitimate Cy Young chance. His ERA is under 1 (has been all season) and if he can catch Jenks in saves (he has 34) he might win it.

Answer 10

Mariano Rivera is the best closer in baseball today and the best ever. I'm not a Yankee fan and I would take him over everyone else.

Answer 11

as a lot as 1884 pitchers were no longer allowed to throw overhand. Throwing underhand positioned far a lot less rigidity on your elbow and shoulder and pitchers might want to pitch very just about on a daily basis. Radbourn all started seventy 3 of providence's 112 video games that 3 hundred and sixty 5 days. In 1884 the NL replaced the rule of thumb to allow overhand pitching. provided that Radbourn had already been in the league for decades, i think he nevertheless pitched more desirable underhand on the time. even with the undeniable fact that, he must have began to throw overhand and dealt with the more desirable positioned on and tear on his arm, as right here 3 hundred and sixty 5 days his video games and innings comprehensive dropped and by no skill back got here decrease back to his 1883-80 4 factor. nevertheless, 60 wins is loopy. If a modern-day pitcher made 36 begins in a three hundred and sixty 5 days and had an same prevailing percentage AND an same percentage of selections (Radbourn were given the decision in both seventy one or seventy 2 of his 75 appearances), we'd want to have a 30 sport winner.