Us History: Should Puritan leaders have banished Anne Hutchinson? Why or Why Not?

Question

I am having trouble answering this question any help or ideas would be greatly apprieciated. Thank You.

Answer 1

I don't think anyone should be punished for having different beliefs than the general public. I find it especially hypocritical that they banished her for her beliefs when they came to America for religious freedom.

Answer 2

Well my personal opinion says that she shouldn't have, but if she was living in that kind of society, then yes she should have been abolished. Hopes this helps.