Are you a Murderer?

Question

If you kill yourself can you be considered a murderer? What about if you shoot someone and then yourself and you die first? Technically the only sin you committed was harming someone, they didnt die on your watch, cause your watch is stopped-your dead.

Answer 1

You do make sense

Answer 2

Go by the sense cause & effect. Whatever be the time of ur death, the cause of death of other person is u (and nobody else). Therefore the effect will come on u.

Question comes when u r no more what effect can come on u?

Its a different question.

First u be clear abt. how cause & effect interpreted then comes the next part.

Answer 3

No because the divination of murder is:

The unlawful killing of one human by another, especially with premeditated malice.

A murderer is:
a person who commits murder.


The only time that would be considered murder, is if you are conjoined twins and one kills themself, the other twin cannot live unless some miracle happens so you are killing them as well.

Answer 4

Very interesting thory... no matter what you will pay for your sins. Unless you repent as you are about to die... even then people who commit suicide go to hell. hmmm.... I think if you kill yourself you ae no a murderer only a sad person.... you still go to hell though... I think if you shoot someone and you die first it still counts as you murdering them, because you caused their death.

Answer 5

BUT, even if you die first, you still fired the bullet that killed them, so yes, you are a murderer.

Answer 6

Whether you die first or later, if you shoot someone and he died. You are murderer.

Answer 7

If you kill yourself, yes that is murder. It would not matter at what time you expire, if your bullet hit another with intention to kill them and they died, it is murder.

Answer 8

if you take life you are a murderer

Answer 9

I... don't think I'm a murderer.

Answer 10

No, but I want to hump your leg!