Who's the top dawg? Dark Phoenix vs Thanos (w/ the Infinite Gems)?

Question

No parameters but they're dukin' it out on a distant planet so that innocent bystanders don't get hurt.

Character:
-For anyone that's ever heard of the "Infinity Wars", Thanos is the super bas@$$ that decided to take on the Marvel Universe (1,2 or 3 heroes at a time) just to impress Death.

Answer 1

You need a bit more explaining... dark phoenix is omnipotent , EVENTUALLY! she nees to use her powers in order for them to grow geometrically. Now thanos has his powers and when giving him the gems he has the nigh omnipotency on the spot.... he would wipe her out fo existance in a single blow. but if the battle to place around dark phoenix's prime then noone could win against her. Korvak, Who completely controlled cosmic even better then phoenix, couldn't take her down unless he did so earlier in her life. so int he begining thanos has it, but in the end Noone beats phoenix.

EDit: oh and also although thanos does have control over space/time/reality ect... phoenix contains the same powers btu has one advantage when she gained in power. she could turn other peoples powers off.(for all non comic geeks note how in x2 nightcrawler could not teleport, basicly beacuse the phoenix says so.)(for comic geeks, i pretty much assume that i don't need to cite a time, she did it so often it isn't even funny.)

Double edit: and her powers couldn't be contorlled by the mind gem bcuz they don't stem from psychosis anymore, when she goes dark phoenix she taps directly into the power cosmic... and there is no gem controllling that power.

Answer 2

Dark Phoenix regardless of being Dark or White, The Phoenix is equivalent to The Living Tribunal who is second most powerful Marvel character after the One-Above-All. The Phoenix is his counterpart, his equal. The Phoenix renewed the entire Earth when it was plagued with demons. The Living Tribunal was suppose to destroy the planet when the Phoenix, his counterpart intervened. So, both Phoenix and Living Tribunal has limitless power that is far beyond the infinity gems combined. The Phoenix force existed since the birth of the universe (the Big Bang)- the cosmic web- and can yeild power throughout the multiverse, is omnipotent, omniscient, a cosmic entity, the child of the universe, guardian of the M'Karann crystal that has infinite universal storage space, immortal, and can only get stronger Google times whenever it uses its powers.

Answer 3

Thanos definitely has this one. Even before acquiring all of the Infinity Gems, he had to defeat those that held them. With the gems, Thanos can control all time, space, and reality. Everything in the universe can be manipulated by his will. Thanos also has superior intelligence and a methodical mind that is necessary to use the gauntlet and defeat his enemies. The only exception to this rule is if he can keep the glove on his hand, and if his love for Mistress Death does not get into the way.

Answer 4

The Infinity Gauntlet is also one of my favorite series, and Valkrye gets cool points for (a) being a girl who knows as much as she does about this and (b) answering correctly.

In addition, I can add that the Phoenix Force is the totality of all psychic energy in the universe. As is the Mind Gem. I'm willing to bet that the Mind Gem alone can completely control AND is absolutely immune to the Phoenix Force.

AND there's still all those other gems. So ANYONE with the Infinity Gauntlet can wield the Phoenix Force, if I understand things correctly, and I own quite a few books considered canon on the subject.

Answer 5

I do not know who is Thanos but Dark Phoenix pretty powerful.

Answer 6

I've heard that Dark Phoenix could have taken on Galactus and won. so I'd vote for her.

Answer 7

Really not sure about this one

Answer 8

1st- what the hell are u talking about
2nd thanks for the points

Answer 9

Thanks to each and everyone of you for the replies.