Who, if anybody, is Peyton Manning worth trading for?

Question

Its a keeper League..
Here's my line-up
Peyton Manning QB
LaMont Jordan RB
Warrick Dunn RB
Hines Ward WR
Santana Moss WR
Keenan McCardell WR
Tony Gonzalez TE
Neil Rackers K
Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Bench:
Trent Green QB
Jake Delhomme QB
Deuce McAllister RB
Muhsin Muhammad WR
Zach Hilton TE
Atlanta Falcons

I have 2 good back up QB's that could be starters on alot of teams .. What do you guys think i should do?

do i trade Manning? if so for who? or do i just keep him?

Even though every year Peyton is ranked nomber one QB, he never finishes the seaon as the #1 QB .. i actually hink Delhomme wil finish #1

Thats all he's worth Boldin, or Fitzgerald??

the guy that said trade him for Keyshawn .. ha .. i just released Johnson ..

Answer 1

I would definetely trade him for a RB. Delhomme and Green with both have great years. You're RBs are weak. Yeah Dunn might get a lil more attention if Duckett is traded but McAllister is gone after the world saw Bush in the last preseason game. You definetly need to trade for a good RB. Look at your options, but with Peyton on your side, you're gonna have some leverage, you might even be able to get two RBs out of him.

Answer 2

You need to put Delhomme in Mannings place and trade Manning for a WR like Keyshawn Johnson. Both play for Carolina but probably will gain you some points together. Maybe trade him for Steve Smith.

Answer 3

Peyton is a stud and I would hold onto him. What you should do is package up one of your bench qb's and maybe a wr or rb for a solid stud rb. Your backs are kind of weak and there just isn't enough depth there. Try and trade up. If you can keep Peyton, then do it, but if you need to trade him, you can only get Johnson, Tomlinson, and Alexander for him. Top tier RB for a top tier QB.

Answer 4

in the adventure that they ever needed to commerce Peyton Manning do you already recognize what the Colts might want to desire in go back? we are talking Ware, draft possibilities, way more effective than Dallas is keen to resign. besides, Peyton gained't desire a commerce. Did Favre even as the Packers drafted Rodgers? Peyton will opt to coach luck and groom him to be an rather good QB of the destiny. He needs to stay a Colt and Indianapolis is winless on the prompt - why commerce your starter for a rookie and threat yet another negative season?

Answer 5

You've got some great depth at QB so I would sit tight for a week or two and hope Manning blows up and then trade him for a better RB if at all possible.

Answer 6

NO! Don't trade Peyton. He's an amazing player. He's considered one of the best QB in football. He also seems like a good guy (which won't help you in Fantasy FB; but at least you know he won't assault someone and get suspended.)

I'd keep him...unless you can get Matt Hasselbeck, of course.

Answer 7

If it's a keeper league then you should keep him around till you see his numbers go down signifcantly. At that point get a young qb.

Answer 8

Definitely keep him. He will get you good numbers year after year. In a keeper league that is definitely what you are looking for. Your back ups are ok but not the caliber of peyton. KEEP HIM

Answer 9

Depending on the scoring for your league, I would trade him for Larry Johnson. That guy's going to have huge numbers this year.

Answer 10

i would trade him to get a top tier rb like alexander, johnson, or tomlison. since your in a keeper league you need a rb that you can keep for a while or trade for picks or do both.