Fantasy Football Keepers... Who should I keep???

Question

I get to keep no more than three of these WR...who do you think I should keep.

M. Booker (Mia)
D. Branch (NE)
R. Ferguson (GB)
Rod Smith (Den)
A. Toomer (NYG)
J. Walker (Den)

What do you guys think?

Answer 1

Keep Ferguson, Toomer and Walker.

Chambers is the guy in Miami and no. 2 is the TE McMichaels plus Miami is going to pound the ball on the ground with Ronnie Brown this year so Booker is not a keeper.

Branch is still a holdout so he can't be relied on. Brady spreads the ball around pretty well in New England anyway.

Smith and Toomer can be tossups but since I feel Toomer is a good red-zone target, I give him the edge.

Answer 2

First of all, there's no point keeping Booker or Ferguson.

Beyond that, you have an interesting dilemma. On the one hand, (as somebody else mentioned) Branch is currently a holdout. On the other hand, I generally don't like to have two WRs from the same team - unless I pick up the second one in the later rounds (meaning I wouldn't waste keeper positions on both). The other things for you to consider are: 1. your league's draft order (and your place in it) and 2. how likely somebody else is to pick up the decent-quality WR you don't keep.

If Branch ends his holdout prior to your draft (or your deadline for naming your keepers, if there's any difference), I'd keep Branch, Smith and Toomer. If Branch is still out by the time you need to make your decision, keep Smith, Toomer and Walker.

Answer 3

Keep Branch, Ferguson, Smith, and Toomer.

Answer 4

Smith, Walker, Branch

Answer 5

Smith, Toomer, and Walker

Answer 6

Branch, Toomer, and Smith

Answer 7

Smith, Amani, Booker

Answer 8

branch, smith & walker

Answer 9

Ugh.