Which comes first, the tune or its use?

Question

Does a composer wake up with a tune in his head and think what do to with it, or does he tell himself that he needs a good tune for whatever, and then proceeds to think of one?

Answer 1

I've done both, but then again, I'm not a very good songwriter.

Answer 2

For me, it depends.
There have been songs I wrote lyrics to AFTER I wrote the music.
And then just the opposite.
I do find it more difficult to write music AFTER the words, though.
Seems the music is always there, floating.

BTW - if you are looking for some ideas, try this:
Play your guitar (piano, whatever) and record it while you hum various melody lines...toss in some non-word vowels or other sounds.
Play it back a few days later and I bet you'll come up with some interesting words based on what you THOUGHT you were saying.

Answer 3

It differs. Some people just hum random tunes, some write lyrics or have an idea and try and write a tune to go with it.

Answer 4

It works both ways, but I have found the tunes that just come to me are better than the forced ones.

Answer 5

I think s/he probably has a tune come, then maybe thinks of suitable words to fit the mood. I write fantastic songs in my dreams..........but I can't remember them when I wake up.

Answer 6

If it is supposed to couple with another piece of art such as a movie or a play, then they use the script for inspiration. If not its most likely just an expression of something else.

Answer 7

the first

Answer 8

well i think all the great composers had the tune in their heads first n if u come to think of it, i guess it makes sense u cant force urself to compose somethin beautiful..well thats one gurl's opinion..bye4now..chichi..

Answer 9

In my case, the tune, but many others write lyrics then the melody. What ever floats your boat, I guess.

Answer 10

Some of each.