What is the name of this artist ?

Question

Hi guys, I need your help. I've watched recently SYTYCD Season 2, and there was a contemporary routine with Ivan and Natalie(i'm not sure about the girl). The songs name was "Why" , but I can't remember the name of the group or the artist. I found 61 songs with this name , but I need the right one. After the routine the judge Mary(the crazy one) cried a little bit. I can't say exactly which episode was that, but I hope you got it.

Answer 1

Annie Lennox

Answer 2

Jason Aldean