English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

i have a theory ginny will be a horcrux

2006-08-15 00:55:16 · 6 answers · asked by jamie braun 2 in Arts & Humanities Books & Authors

6 answers

The only problem with the theory that Harry is the last Horcrux is that Voldemort didn't hear all of the prophecy. He only heard the beginning about a child born as the seven month dies being able to destory him. He never heard the "only one can survive" part. The trouble with the theory that Ginny is a Horcrux is that she was controlled by a Horcrux, I can't be sure, but I don't think that one Horcrux can make another *otherwise wouldn't there be more than seven?*. I think that while characters will die * and probably popular characters at that*, Harry will survive. I don't think that even JK would want the kind of backlash that killing the main character would entail.

2006-08-15 02:18:51 · answer #1 · answered by Jessica H 3 · 0 0

If I remember correctly, a person CANNOT be a horcrux, because anything can happen to that person. V couldn't be sure that the person would be kept alive, and there goes his horcrux. Also, think about it, how could Ginny be a horcrux. V wasn't there to make her a horcrux and the old man he killed in the beginning of HBP was not important enough for him to use in making one. His horcruxes were complete before Ginny was born. Harry's murder was supposed to help make the last one and Ginny is younger than Harry.

Horcruxes-the ring, the diary, the locket, something of Griffindor's (I'm thinking the hat), something of Ravenclaw's (I have no idea what), V himself carries on soul piece, Hufflepuff's cup, and one other thing that Harry is going to discover along the way. Nothing we've ever seen or heard of before.

2006-08-15 03:01:20 · answer #2 · answered by Jessie P 6 · 0 0

see, i thik that the thing goes that voldemort was trying to get his final horecrux, so when he heard the profecy, then he thought, "o, i can make this kid my last horcrux by killing him and defeting him". there is also the theory that fawkes is a horcrux for dumbledore, which could be true becuase he died, and then fawkes burst into flame and "left".
(plus, she said that he is really dead, snape is good, hermione and harry wont be together, but she will be with someoneelse close to her(hint hint RON hint hint), and that the last word in the book is scar)
if u have ne more questions, i read these books lie crazy!! :D

2006-08-15 01:37:28 · answer #3 · answered by reading rules! 4 · 0 0

i dunno about the horcruxs but i think that dumbledore and snape came up with a plan so that instead of draco killing dumbledore it was snape so that draco could remain innocent and that when we next see them the will be under the protection of the order and so will narcissa. i also think that there is a chance that ginny will tag along with harry ron and hermione or at least try to till the trio do sumthing to make her go home. i think tonks will finally persuade lupin to accept her. i also think that something big will happen to spoil bill and fluer big day-either something involving deatheaters or molly with possinly a little help from ginny.
amy(the girl with way to much time on her hands atm)
xxx

2006-08-15 03:18:44 · answer #4 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

People will waste tons of money and time on the poorly written slop, then waste more money going to see the crappy movies. Why? Because they are sheep without an individual interest in anything. And why is that? Because they are influenced by the media and just can't seem to think for themselves.

And no, I'm not a religious "thou shalt not do witchcraft" person. I am simply a fan of truly GOOD and REAL books, movies, music and other stuff. I am opinionated and cynical and I don't really care what you think.

Enjoy the Harry hype!

Oh, and learn to spell. It would be "theories" not "theorys". Please!

2006-08-15 03:19:54 · answer #5 · answered by Anonymous · 0 1

yeah, one of my thoughts is that Harry is that last horcrux ... neither can live while the other is alive ... and so one w/ the prophecy ... but then, Voldemort wouldn't really try to destroy Harry cuz he'd be destroying one of his horcruxes ... I don't know ... I love the books and movies though!

2006-08-15 01:45:01 · answer #6 · answered by Hollyhocks 4 · 0 0

fedest.com, questions and answers