English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

I am not denying Israels right to exist I just wanna see what you guys think about what happened in 1948. I personally believe that Britain( the west in general also) is the cause of modern day terrorism because of sykes-picot and the balfour declaration. They really messed around with the Arabs by splitting them into nations and supporting tyran regimes over them. They also pissed them off when they supported Israel to go ahead and build a country over the land of other people. I do not believe in the whole God giving land to someone so please do not use illogical arguments.

2006-08-13 04:29:04 · 11 answers · asked by Ignorant_American 3 in Politics & Government Politics

11 answers

I absolutely agree with you.There is no doubt that creation of Israel on Arabs' land has been the root cause of Muslims unrest along with many more steps that were meant to harm Muslims, Muslim's unity and their interests all over.Jews claim that they had the right to return to their promised land and that God has returned their land to them.What about Red Indians' land the south African land Rodesian land the Australian Land Dravidian land(the whole of IndoPakistan) and many more.The Britain, the whole Europe, USA and Russia too are the real cause of today's unrest and chaos in the whole world.and when they don't want to see the obvius,the Mslims feel let down.Coupled with false propaganda against their religion,way of living,their Prophet etc,etc.and INJUSTICE meted out to them(look at case of Lebanon) at all the forums which are controlled by the West give birth to Osama bin Ladins.By the way who is resposible for the rise of OBL.It was the US.Who created Taliban? It is not an ancient history It happened just yesterday.For God's sake try to understand and don't destroy the world through hypocracy,treachry and fraud.We don't now demand to undo Israel but at least let the Palitenians also have the right to exist and live.So is the case o Kashmeer,Chechnia,Moro land,some other states in the earstwhile Soviet Union.Conterary to what is happening to the Muslim cause,the West recognised indepedence of all old staes of Soviet Russiaas Independent States but when it came to recognition of Chechnia every one of Christian dominated countries of the West started labelling Chechens as terrorists.When East Temur declared Independece from Indonesia all Western countries recognised East Temur and not only that they arranged a resolution passed by UN,SC for holding aplebisite.Why? The Muslims believe and rightly so that all these states were christian states,while ,despite the fact that two esolutions were passed by the UN,SC more than half a century ago for holding a plebesite in case of Kashmeer and as the Territory belongs to Muslims they never let the resolutions acted upon.Only one Resolution,there goes Afghanistan to Tora Bora caves and wipeped out from the map of the world,and hundreds of innocent Afghans and Pakistanis to GNB, Cuba, just no resolution but still there goes Iraq to Abu Gharib prison only because thes poor countries were Muslim countries Look at Israel she has thrown dozens of SC resolution down the comode with impunity but not a word of advice from the US.India has spurned two resolutions on the face of the world body,no ta world from the Heavy Weights.For God's sake think Oh Westerns think with your own brains.Do not be swayed away by the propeganda of the Jewish Media and Loby.Bush and Blair are slaves to the Jews. Don't believe them.

2006-08-13 06:27:40 · answer #1 · answered by riaz 2 · 0 0

First of all let me give 2 thumbs up to you, cause you are the first one who did research in this subject historically here.. everybody else are talking about the subject without knowing a jack.
The History goes way back to days of Moses..
Moses got the word from God about the promise land.. and the Jews ended up in the Palestinian lands.. and the Palestinian lands at the time was occupied by the Palestinians themselves, who were well known as worriers!
Anyway.. things develop and King Solomon , then David become the kings of Israel.. and years goes by.. things go bad.. the Roman empire become the real ruler of Israel.. Then again a Christian King takes over .. then the Islamic invasion happens.. after that you know the rest.. the British came way years later..
So if you look to the facts : We would not blame the British.. because this was going to happen regardless of UK.

2006-08-13 11:39:04 · answer #2 · answered by guy_from_there 3 · 0 0

Of course NOT, Palestine was taken from its people by colonial powers. The modern day terrorism had its seed sown in the beginning of last century. They came occupied Arab land and exploited its resources and divided into mini states. Not only that, but they brought hundred of thousands of European Jews and settle them in Palestine. Where is the justice in this? just imagine that some bully come and kick you out of your own home where you live all your life and then brought some stranger from no where to occupy it and over the years started believing it is actually his. I tell you TERRORISM will continue as long as the core of the problem is not solved. I think the worse has not come yet!!!

2006-08-13 11:48:00 · answer #3 · answered by Kanan 3 · 0 0

The main reason the Israelis were given this land was because of the Holocaust. The Palestinians were given their own peace of land, but they decided to fight and try to destroy Israel which of course failed miserably. As for your argument that this was Arab land you are largely correct. If the Jews were given their own land why was it in the Middle East and not in Germany where the Holocaust took place? Well, the Germans would not like it for one and the area of Palestine was not greatly organised or populated. The Israelis were not originally given Jerusalem but when they were attacked they took it. Everyone in the Middle East needs to accept Israel because they are not going anywhere anytime soon.

2006-08-13 11:37:23 · answer #4 · answered by bumpocooper 5 · 0 0

High Five!! Finally a sane question!! Man you just got it, U Rock! Keep up the good work ;)
This whole freak show started decades ago by the israelis claimin a land that's not theirs... God would'nt give them a land that's not theirs, God wouldn't want innocent ppl to get killed and kicked outta their homes! That's not fair, God would sure want peace and justice!
Well if it were so then all muslims would have the right to build and empire and claim a land that's not theirs, and so would christians! i mean, come on! think about it! it's just not RIGHT, doesn't make any sense! so dnt mess with these ppl and then come out sayin they r terrorists for claimin their own homes, their own right to exist...

2006-08-13 11:52:19 · answer #5 · answered by Yasmine A 1 · 0 0

You'll never get anywhere with this sort of argument. You can't go back to 1948. You have to deal with what you have now.. Arabs-Muslims-Islamists do not own the world. They are even welcome in "non-Arabic" lands like Europe and America. So what is their bloody problem? Can they not share? Must they all be so exclusive (as is their so-called religion) and always hate everything and everybody that is not like them or people who don't think like them? Will they ever learn to be more open-minded to the world at large or forever remain in their shell and crying "why me"? like little babies?

2006-08-13 11:38:27 · answer #6 · answered by robert43041 7 · 0 0

The other people you are talking about is England....it was their land, and they sold it to the UN to give to the Israelites.......No one split them into nations, the countries were there for 1000's of years...yes, sometimes under different names....but they have been there......well, if YOU believed in God, maybe the argument would not be so illogical....and by the way, the land belonged to no one 3500 years ago........belief in God or not......

2006-08-13 11:38:26 · answer #7 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

why do you say it was Arab land? You clearly have read that the British had taken possession of it. Yet for some reason you ignore any claim that Israel may have and just say it is Arab land. If you ignore the British authority then please explain why. And why then you chose not to ignore the Arab claims based on the same reasoning.

2006-08-14 00:23:09 · answer #8 · answered by unicorn 4 · 0 0

That land was never owned by Arabs. It has always been in a state of of constant flux for milleniums. The Arabs took it from the Christians in the Crusades. The Christians from the fallen Roman empire before that. From the Jews by the Romans before that. The Jews from the Phillistines before that

2006-08-13 11:36:08 · answer #9 · answered by bjmarchini 2 · 0 1

The UN declare it in 1948, but God gave it to them long before that. It's illogical only if you don't believe it, it's illogical not to believe.

2006-08-13 11:39:09 · answer #10 · answered by Zen 4 · 0 0

fedest.com, questions and answers