would you trade Ryan Howard and Julio Lugo for Derek Jeter and Pedro Feliz?

Question

H2H league and here's my team

C-Posada
1B-Ortiz
2B- Orlando Hudson
3B- Aaron Hill
SS-Julio Lugo
OF-Gary Matthews Jr.
OF-Mike Cameron
OF-Kenny Lofton
UTIL-Ryan Howard
BN-Edmonds
BN-Milton Bradley
BN- Mark Teahen

H2H league and here's my team

C-Posada
1B-Ortiz
2B- Orlando Hudson
3B- Aaron Hill
SS-Julio Lugo
OF-Gary Matthews Jr.
OF-Mike Cameron
OF-Kenny Lofton
UTIL-Ryan Howard
BN-Edmonds
BN-Milton Bradley
BN- Mark Teahen

and the stats are
H/AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB BB K FPCT AVG
i'm only showing the offense numbers, because pitching is not involved in this trade

Answer 1

No, no, no.

Answer 2

NO WAY!!!
wow, you have argueably the 2 best first baseman.. there is no way you can do that trade..

Depending on what you need you could a knock out pitcher with this guy, and maybe more..

if your looking to get a bat ot 2, i'd go for the big third base bat of david wright .. but you could use some help in the outfield, so go for Vernon Wells, Carlos Lee type player .. right now you could get pretty much any player you wnt with Howard, don t settle with Jeter and Feliz

Answer 3

Pedro Feliz is a terrible contribution to a fantasy team, and Julio Lugo is going to start losing all his playtime to Furcal at SS, Kent at 2B, and Nomar at 1B on the Dodgers. So they're basically null and void in this trade.

If you want to trade Howard for Jeter, that's your business. You will need a new SS. But I personally wouldn't trade the NL HR leader for Jeter, who despite having a career year in most categories, has lost all pop in his bat. You could probably trade Howard for Tejada. I would personally attempt a trade of Edmonds or Bradley + someone weak on your pitching staff for Carlos Guillen who is putting up equal numbers to Lugo. Or Bill Hall who will give you more power.

Answer 4

No, you should not make that deal. In terms of value, it's completely off. I could see you trading Howard for Jeter and Feliz (still not equal value) but Lugo does not need to be included.

Your team lacks power, outside of Ortiz and Howard, so I would look for someone with more power than Feliz. He is too inconsistent and probably will not give you 30 HRs.

Bottom line, sometimes you have to overpay to fill holes on your team but I just don't see how this trade accomplishes that.

Answer 5

i ought to easily no longer try this commerce, even in spite of the undeniable fact that the archives you gave us is constrained (sorry). All Howard's doing is hitting the ball to the subsequent county and Lugo is nice if no longer astounding. Jeter and Sexson aren't any further having good years (a minimum of no longer by way of their criteria besides) and Howard delivers you with extra HRs and RBIs than Sexson or Jeter, so please do no longer try this commerce

Answer 6

no- Feliz is a bum. Jeter is an upgrade at SS, but not enough to offset losing Howard.

Answer 7

yes, trade. howard will break his arm hitting a home run and lugo will break his leg stealing 2nd. you will come out smelling like a rose. trust me.

Answer 8

No way I would do that trade if I were you man. I would think you'd be better off staying out of that trade.

Answer 9

Hell no!! Why would you even think about this!!

Answer 10

no

Answer 11

no