Should I trade Schilling and Oswalt for Utley?

Question

I know for sure I won't finish in 1st. Looking for next year to win. What do you guys think? Chase Utley has 5 tool talent.

Answer 1

Yes. He's a stud. Though whoever you are trading to will probably win the title this year with that trade, so it' a win-win.

For whoever isn't reading, this is a KEEPER league.

Utley is in only his 2nd full year. 2B is one of the weakest posiitons and Utley is just getting warmed up. Schilling has maybe a year or two left, and Oswalt's frame doesn't seem likely to hold up long-term. I'd definitely do this.

Answer 2

I would trade Schilling for Utley. He dosen't have much keeper value left, while Oswalt clearly will help your team in the coming years. However, I would have the the owner throw in a marginal pitcher with decent strike- out and era numbers to replace Schilling in your line- up before doing the trade.

Answer 3

Absolutely not. 2 for 1. NO!! Schilling and Oswalt are some of the best pitchers in the league.

Answer 4

you have got to admit, utley is real good...he has a 35 game hitting streak which just got ended a few days ago...posting above a 300 avg. more than a handful of homeruns...any fantasy manager would love to have him....but to give schilling up and roy oswalt...thats just crazy....i would do it if i had PLENTY of more help pitching and you are in desperate need. But for the sake of pitching....i wouldnt do.

Answer 5

Utley is good but not worth BOTH of the pitchers, trade one of them for him.

Answer 6

I would say no, but if it's a keepers league i would be tempted to make that trade as well but i would definetly not trade both pitchers not even for Soriano.

Answer 7

No what are you crazy!!!! Or it depends who is on your bench.

Answer 8

if you really need hitting