Do you think Israel is a legitimate state? YES or NO?

Question

Please say either yes or no

Answer 1

NO.

Israel has no rights to exist there and the present estabilishment done forcibly and illegally. And so the reason for the crisis is because of Israel and its supporters.

Here is historically true arguments thats why some people get angry which prove their cunningness and the spread of false propaganda through state controlled medias.

Israel is not a soverign democratic country.

It has hunderds of Nuclear war heads according to Murdochai Vanunu (a Jews findings and statements).

It is not signed NPT (Nuclear non-Proliferation Treaty) Protocol.

It does not allow IAEA inspections(International Automic Energy Agency).

There is no peace to Israel without justice. Israel is not a sovereign country and dont have the right to exist in the middle east. It was established 60-years before on the blood of Palestinians who live there for several Hundred years.

Israel may be existing some 3000 years before but extincted the at the same time.

Over the years, Several empires changes, the people converted to true religions. The land is historically belongs the Palestine people who live there.

The recent Israel was forcibly established by collecting the Jews from all over the world and by killing defenceless righteous people.

Answer 2

Israel was created Illigally, with the blood of the palestinians. its an illigal aparthied police state, that has brutalized the population around it . although it has done so, it was created illigitimately but there is no reason why it cant become one. at this point in history YEs it is a ligitimate state but still created illigally .

well ill retract my previous answer, with the current crisis Israel is acting more like a brutal savage then a legitimate state . so NO untill it stops invading its neighbors and seazing more land then it is not a legitimate state .

Answer 3

Yes

Answer 4

NOOOOOO, not in its present form, and certainly not in its arrogant and aggressive form.
Yaz is very right.
BUT the arabs who lived there sold a lot of land to the Jewish National Fund and by 1930 the JNF owned 1,533,400 acres of land.
These same Arabs boycotted the UNSCOP comittee meetings in 1947, as they did not want their land partitioned. This gave the Jewish settlers ( who were still significantly less in population and landholding), to present their side and the UN subsequently decided to partition somebody elses land and make a jewish state there.
The Jewish aim is made clear in a letter from Ben Gurion to his wife where he says ' establish a Jewish state at once, even it is not in the whole land....the rest will come in the course of time.

Answer 5

You can argue that the UN did not have a right to form Israel at the expense of the Palestinian people, but you have to admit that Israel "earned" its rights but the subsequent wars it fought and won.

If you deny that Israel won its right to exist, then you also deny the rights of any country who's borders were determined by armed conflict.

Answer 6

No.. definitely not. It is not legitimate to steal ppl's land

I'll let this link speaks for itself. Check it out
http://www.ccmep.org/delegations/maps/palestine.html#2

Answer 7

No.

Who gave legitimacy to Israel ? UN.

Who doesn't respect UN and then give no more legitimacy to UN ? USA

So, I'll give legitimacy to Israel when USA will respect UN.

Answer 8

well to my understanding NO. but if you ask about Jews then they were some living or should i say the origin of that land were living together in harmony with Arabs and with every one and the land was called Palestine.

Answer 9

Yes or no is innacurate and unifnormed.
But since you dont care.

Yes.

Answer 10

YES