Which catcher should i keep johjima or willingham?

Question

i only can keep one for the rest of the year, who do u think will have the best production for the final two months of the regular season?

Answer 1

willingham has some flexibility as to moving into the outfield, and has better power numbers. johjima has a better average, less home runs, but more games.

for a catcher....i'd keep johjima. better average, still some power. willingham is kinda streaky with his .257, and olivo is a pretty good catcher that may oust willingham for consistent starts.

Answer 2

Willingham has the advantage because he is catcher eligible but doesn't actually catch. He'll probably start more games the rest of the way and won't wear down as much as a guy like Johjima who does nothing but catch. Unless it's a deep keeper league or your league has put outs as a category, Willingham should be more productive rest of the season.

Answer 3

If your leagues point system is better for power, then definately keep Willingham. He not only hits well, but he plays C and OF so he helps tremendously with injuries.

Answer 4

I'd keep Willingham, he's younger even though they're both rookies.

Answer 5

Johjima