How can Israel win a war, when it only kills civilians and not combatants?

Question

The cowardly use of long range bombing just hasn't worked.

fishball, go back to your fish eating and switch off Fox News, because you are just not smart enough. Maybe those fishballs will help you.

j_piccioni, Sitting on the fence only gives you a sore butt. However I agree with most of what you say. Just imagine locked in your home with the fire power from the FBI coming from outside, would you not throw out some stones to counter them.

Answer 1

The question you should be asking is how does Israel target hezbollah with bunker busting 5000 pound bombs and not kill innocent women and children. so how many hezzas were killed in that building?
Which intelligence determined that hezbollahs were in that building and how many?
You should not let spins from fishpot and his types get to you. They are the cruel versions of excuses Israel is advancing for killing 1300 innocent lives and being fed to her citizens to intimidate people with on this forum.
they dont have any other excuse apart from 'we destroy the banks, airports abd buildings because hezbollahs are hiding in it.
If hezbollahs are hiding among civilians and they are being taken out how come they are still firing the missiles?

Answer 2

The problem is the so called combatants find it neccassary to hide among the civilian population, therefore making it impossible to destroy them without civilian casualties. As sad as that may seem. To me if your willing to start a war than be man enough to fight like a soldier, not some coward that hides behind kids and women. You know what though? They know they can't win that way and would rather see the innocent pay the price than give up on their useless cause, which would only bring more death and destruction to this world. They are terrorist, always have been, always will be.

Answer 3

The goal for Israel is to clear the population and make land theft a bit easier by decreasing weapons of the freedom fighters. They do not value human life at all. We have seen evidence of this in the Palestinian communities. Israel is a terrorist nation with American funding that allows and backs it's murderous agenda. Their ground battle along the border failed as they went running back to Israel, that is why they bomb from the air. They wouldn't stand a chance if they fought like men.

Answer 4

israel doesn't care.
weeks into the conflict, at it is clear that israel is a facist ragime intent on enthnic cleansing.
again hizb have been the first to walk up to the negotiation table with a reasonable starting point... israelis back to israel, and they will disarm. but once again the israelis have ignored this. so how do you make a person stop firing a gun if they have already decided they are going to pull the trigger no matter what.
they want to kill as many non-jewish people as possible whilst they have the chance, and hizb. is just a thorn in their side and a great excuse.

Answer 5

And what about the cowardly use of long range missiles into Israeli cities by Hezbollah?

You know - you might get a bit more sympathy if you put forward an Intelligent Argument for your case, rather than just a brainwahed (do you have a brain?) point of view.

Ps I am not an Israeli or American!

Answer 6

Hezbollah have stated, that when the two Israeli soldiers were ' kidnapped ', they were eight miles inside Lebanon.
The Israelis have stated that the civilians from southern Lebanon had to be moved, because they supported Hezbollah. Now that sounds to me like they were ' deliberately ' targeting civilians.
When these Lebanese do go back, there will be nothing there for them, everything has been flattened.
Hezbollah hide among civilians, do you believe they eat babies too?

Answer 7

Its WAR . there are no winners . only losers. no one will win cos its not an conventional war. its a war against terrorists who mix in with civilians. the civilians are and will continue to be the biggest losers and have the most casualties. I hope it stops but being realistic about it i don't think it will stop. there will always be unrest in the middle east. when this one does end another one will start. What a crazy world we live in.

Answer 8

I am completly impartial on this topic. But you seem very one sided.

Yes civilians have been killed but on BOTH sides!!! it is not just Israel killing people.
All this war is doing is creating the next generation of hate between 2 groups of people.

Lets just hope it all gets sorted soon, and send our thoughts and prayers to the innocent people.

ps, if this is not what you wanted to hear, then please don't add an extra comment to disregard what I have said as you have done to a previous answer! You asked the question and this is my answer.

Answer 9

the reason being that there is not any thank you to "win" that war in absolute words. Israel is surrounded by ability of enemies who, if given the prospect, could gladly unite to strike against Israel. on the same time as the Jewish state is powerful it is not girded against attack such that it ought to fend off assaults from all Arab countries and strikes from Hezbollah besides. additionally, if a war could desire to erupt to that volume the US could be obligated to play a place, the two diplomatic or militia. The ensuing conflict could disillusioned worldwide potential markets and can be one that pulls in superpowers on one factor or the different increasing the prospect to worldwide secure practices and stability. The war between Egypt and Israel of the 1970's almost had this result while the then Soviet Union enable us to diplomats understand that if Israel pushed into Cairo or destroyed the Egyptian 0.33 military they could be forced to installation their forces to stay away from it. that would have required a US reaction and the tip result could have been catastrophic. as a remember of fact that with a brilliant sort of different gamers and worldwide political pastimes resting in this conflict there is not any course to victory different than peace. it is not the will of the UN or any united states of america that this war could desire to final invariably yet till all aspects understand that peace is the victory all of them could desire to point to attain it is going to proceed...

Answer 10

My friend, who told u that Israel can win any war? They can't win any war without the help of USA and Britain. Hizbolla can't win any war without Iran and Syria. These are politics and communalism. Muslims hate Christians and Jews, Jews and Christians hate Muslim. All these religions got this kind of hatred from their holy books; Tora, Bible (Old Testament) and Quran. Yohava or Allah himself ordered Moses to kill and loot innocents;read these books you will know why all these religions hate each other. They never say all religions are equal or all are human beings or sons and daughters of the Great God. They say "MY RELIGION IS CORRECT AND ALL OTHERS ARE ON WRONG PATH".