who is the most under rated qb in the nfl? how about over rated? ever?

Answer 1

The most under rated is trent green.The most over rated has got to be Michael Vick.

Answer 2

Judging from the answers so far, Ben Roethlisberger would be a good pick for underrated. Rather than simply not losing the games, he plays a big part in winning them. Perceptions might be biased because he has struggled in half of his playoff games, but last year showed that the Steelers are much better when he is healthy and in the game. He has achieved quite a bit in only two seasons. Jake Plummer would also be a good choice. He had a phenomenal season last year, yet because he and the entire Broncos team lost one playoff game to a team no one else beat in the playoffs either, the Broncos panicked into trading up to draft a QB and the national media are expecting a Plummer meltdown. On the contrary, both Plummer and Roethlisberger should perform well this year, and it would be neither a surprise nor a fluke if they were to meet again in this season's AFC Championship Game.

As for overrated, Tom Brady certainly is; he is very good, but he is far from the sole reason that the Patriots won championships. And the most overrated now and of all time is almost certainly Kurt Warner. Some rather mediocre QBs have succeeded in the Rams' offense; indeed, the Rams became contenders not when they signed Warner but when they drafted Orlando Pace. A good line, good receivers, and Marshall Faulk made the QB's job far easier.

Answer 3

Honestly, I think it is Michael Vick. I feel it is because the Falcons want him to emphasize his flashiness and running ability so that fans will be willing to come to the games. If he was in a system where he was taught to be a real QB and rely on his overall talent, he would be a great one. I know he is promoted a lot, but like I said, he's just not being utilized correctly. It reminds me of Randall Cunningham when he was here in Philly. I could not stand him or Buddy Ryan.

As for overrated, it has to be Peyton (not Eli) Manning. This will be the test year for him without the option of Edgerrin James to keep the defenses guessing. Marvin Harrison will still be his dependable self but Manning has had a better system built around him than Michael Vick.

This is not sour grapes, but Tom Brady is another example of a good, all-around QB in a dedicated system that enables him to shine like a superstar. Nothing against him, it just proves my point that when it all comes together, a QB can look great. Joe Montana is another one.

Answer 4

under rated- Donavan McNabb; because he has proved himself several times without a real team(ie; they want to the NFC big game 4 times with only him leading the team), and when he finally gets a receiver he goes to the big game. I think they dont give him enough credit. if any of the QB's on other teams would have had the same squad; they may have not produced the same numbers.
Over rated- Michael Vick; everyone hypes him up, and he cant throw a ball to save his life. His younger brother will surpass him. He should be a wide out, cause he runs faster than any other on the team. He is a overpaid QB in my eyes, and John MADDEN always says great things about him. well what do you think

Answer 5

Honestly the most underrated quaterback is Trent Green of the Chiefs. I hate the Chiefs but look at his numbers there Pro Bowl numbers and he doesnt even have great recievers except there TE. Over rated quaterback now that would be Drew Bledsoe of the Cowboys. He can put up numbers but would you want him to lead you 21 down in the 4th quater. He stays in the pocket way tooo long. The most overrated quaterback of all time is Joe Namath all he ever did was guarantee a Super Bowl. If he was that good where was the repeat they didnt lose any stars that offseason. The most underrated quaterback ever would be Bart Starr. He is in the Hall of Fame but most people wouldnt put him as there QB or even a back up. He was the first QB to win back to back superbowls and superbowl one mvp. Come on

Answer 6

I think Alex Smith is under-rated because he's a lot better than the average person thinks he is.

And I think Ben Rothlisberger is a tad bit over-rated. He does just enough not to loose the game for the Steelers, and his supporting cast carries a ton of the load. I doubt he could go to a team with less talent and succeed like Carson Palmer does in Cincinnati or Chris Simms does in Tampa Bay.

Answer 7

Ever? In today's world the most underater QB of all time is EASILY Otto Graham. Based on championships won (which people seem to put SO much weight on) he is EASILY the greatest QB of all time and almost no one knows who he is.

He led the Browns to TEN straight championships and won SEVEN of them.

OVERATED? I'm going with Fran Tarkenton. Other than being able to run for his life, he proved he was veryt average otherwise. He was never able to win a championship despite being on perinial playoff teams with him at the helm. Always a bridesmade. Came to let down an extrodinary defense with his ineptitude.

Answer 8

Under-rated ..got to be Jake Delhomme I probable wont even draft him...he's not all that bad
Over-rated ...how many characters do I get to write with....
Jake Plummer comes to mind never really has done anything since his Cardinal days.........bledsloe....if they don't make the playoffs this year...Let's just say..good for him..his best game was the AFC championship game when Brady was hurt one year
and finally...still with many years to improve Eli had alot of good talent around him to keep him out of the doghouse this year and last

Answer 9

Alex Smith is the most underrated. Over Rated is Eli Manning.

Answer 10

Underrated would have to be David Carr of the Texans, if he can get an O-Line to give him time he could amazing.
Overrated would be Peyton (can't play under pressure) or Vick (great athlete, bad QB)

Answer 11

Underrated - Jake Plummer

Overrated - Ben Roethlisberger