If you believe abortion is Murder why would it be justified if the women was raped?

Question

I'm Pro Choice but I had this lady in said that abortion was Murder but justified abortion if the women was raped, If you belive there is a baby in there, why is it ok to kill it.

I dont have a problem with pro life people or how they feel about the subject , just dont tell me abortion is murder and in the same breath tell me its ok on your terms.

Johnny
At least you have a plan for the baby. Most people like to forget about the baby as soon as its born. I call them love the Fetus and the child people. Mostly Republican not to decrimainte I think there some on both sides, just what I have encounter though

To Johnny that was Love the Fetus and Hate the Child people. I left out a word

Answer 1

Cons always pick and choose when and why someone has an abortion. If they say it's MURDER, then by any means is it murder. Just because the womas was raped doesn't make the baby any more valuable, so it's still murder. They have no stance is talking about morals because they don't know the meaning of it.

Answer 2

Abortion is murder. Both the woman and the baby are the victims, especially in the case of rape. Take the rapist and
make him pay for the care of the mother and the baby, until
the baby reaches 22. Hold him in a work camp in some remote
place like an Alaska prison work camp or something.

I Corinthians 13;8a, Love never fails!!!!!

Answer 3

I had the same run down with a pro lifer. When I asked about cases of rape they replied, "well, that is different and then abortion is justified." I don't understand them but just as we have a right to our opinion so do they.

Answer 4

If abortion is murder, then it is wrong for any reason. I am pro-life and don't understand how other pro-lifers try to make exception for rape. 2 wrongs do not make a right.

Answer 5

Any abortion law or restrictions would have to carry exceptions for the "hard cases" such as these. Any measure that didn't would be barbaric, and should be summarily rejected.

But that's just me. I believe that abortion for other reasons is morally wrong, but I have trouble enforcing such a law.

Answer 6

No, it is not justified even if the woman is raped. The child should not be punished by death for the crime of her father. She is innocent and does not deserve to die. Futhermore, abortion only increases the grief and trauma of a woman who has been raped, and in the case of incest, it allows the pervert to continue his crimes undetected. For more on this specific issue, see:

http://www.deathroe.com/Pro-life_Answers/Answers.cfm?ID=31
http://www.afterabortion.info/Victims/index.htm
http://www.family.org/fofmag/sl/a0039249.cfm
http://www.afterabortion.info/PAR/V2/n1/RAPESUM.htm

For more on abortion in general, see http://Abort73.com

Answer 7

They pick and choose which part of the argument suits their needs. The Rapture Right does the same when referring to the Bible. If it is for their cause, they will recite that verse until your ears bleed. If it is against their cause, they will conveniently forget it is there.

Answer 8

that is still not ok . in my personal opinions. Yet we live in a free country where people get to do cruel and unusual things all the time and never get busted for it.

Answer 9

I have asked that question for years! It's still a life right?

Answer 10

Its not justifiable ever.