Since jews and palestinians both claim rights to the same land, will the war ever end?

Question

these people have been fighting for 1000 years over the same piece of land. Should we really be involved in a war that started before America was a nation? Will anybody win? Is there ANY solution?

Brandon, why did the jews leave the strip last year? Seems to me that if they felt it was theirs, they would have stayed

Answer 1

Solution is that israel either withdraws to its pre-1967 borders as set by the UN. Palestinians won that war the one that lasted for 1000 years since there werent many jews there and the palestinians allowed everyone into their country. After WW2 america and the UK decided to be smart asSes and make a nation to cause instability there. And the story goes on till now. Israel has not failed to have a war with every one of its neighbours. the current lebanon never had a war with palestine. Current palestine never had a war with jordan or egypt. What im getting to is that israel is the cause of the current day situation. Remember hizballah was created only when israel invaded lebanon and the lebanese southerners got fed up.

Answer 2

Since the Israelis have an organized Government and the Land was technically given to them by the UK it is legally theirs. Like anything else in this world, nothing is fair. The religion isnt the problem, its the sovereignty of the land...The palestinians will probably never have their own country. Maybe a province in Israel if they learn a thing or two about seperation of religion and politics. Thats the only way they can deal with a western government with out seeming childish.

Answer 3

1. It will end. Many will die but it will end.

2. It is closer to three thousand years and we have a relationship with Israel. Should we just close our eyes and let them all die when they ask for our help?

3. If anybody survives , they win.

4. Split the baby. In this case, Jerusalem. That is what this is all about. One city. Cut it in have and see if they are satisfied. I am not talking about the land but the ruins. Give each half.

Answer 4

only 50 years not 1000 that is a myth Arab Jews lived in peace un like other places.
1000 years war is a racist account of Jews and Arabs or racist understanding of the Bible.
The people who mass killed Jews were never Arabs most were Westerns or Easterners or Africans.
But the to days war is between Palestinian who are " Jews+ Christians+Muslims" and Zionist Jews not all the Jews are Zionists . If you do not belive me see the this source they are Jews

Answer 5

Actually it is close to 3000 years, and no, I do not see it ending.

I really do not understand why we are so involved in it. It is none of my doing.

You might want to read my last story on my blog, starting with the 7/24 entry.

http://360.yahoo.com/diogenese19348

It pretty much gives my view of the subject in my own warped way.

-Dio

Answer 6

No to all. I don't believe that there is a solution for the problem of organized religion, which is the reason for most wars.

Answer 7

yes there is a solution but the jews will not like it .
RETURN the land to palestine .
THIS would please all the arabs and end the conflict that has existed for 60 years .
WE did not give the kkk mississippi to make them happy .
WHY did we give palestine to the jews.
MEL GIBSON is right .

Answer 8

Since you claim yourself to be an intellect, surely you know that the Palestenians never had a land, they are descendants of nomad tribes that NOBODY, not even their Arab cousins, wanted.

Answer 9

WAY over a 1000 years and it was Israel than and still is

Answer 10

This has been going on for thousands of years & sadly this will more than likely continue long after we are gone.