Is it fair that Israel makes a collective punishment in a whole country?

Question

Does anyone think that Israel is right by making a collective punishment to the whole country of Lebanon ? would the Israelis accept a collective punishment if Lebanon kidnapped 2 soldiers from their borders? is the price the lebanese are paying 3000 billions damage and 800 civilians dead including babies would really lead both countries to peace?

Answer 1

Okay, now I am mad. How in the name of all that is holy can anyone justify Isreal's response to two SOLDIERS being taken by an extremist group. NEVER has a country literally gone out to decimate another country over the issue of two soldiers. This is ridiculous. If anyone doesn't buy the notion that Isreal was just looking for any excuse to do what they are now doing then I give up on the idea of man being an intelligent creature.

Answer 2

we know all that and I stopped seeking fairness cause it's not existed anymore when it comes to Israel American policy, but the problem is that even punishing the group who kidnapped 2 soldiers is unfair as well, Israel Killed Rafeek Hareri and Jobran Twaini, and many more and no one said anything, Israel killed 4 UN peace keepers and same story, Israel killed two brothers who lives in Lebanon (before the kidnapping) who belong to hammas (the new government in Palestine) and no one said anything to Israel, Israel arrested many of Hamas Minsters with no charges and no one said anything, Israel keep killing the Palestinians every single day very brutally and no one saying anything, and the world is angry for 2 stupid soldiers, F U C K the soldiers and Israel.

Answer 3

Yes it's fair. When Hizballah is part of the Lebanese government and the Lebanese government allows Hizballah to carry on the way it has, Israel has the right to defend itself. This whole thing started because Hizballah decided to ambush and kill two Israeli soldiers and kidnap two more. It would end if they would give them back. Israel is destroying the infrastructure that Hizballah uses to stay alive and continue its terrorist activities. The Lebanese need to get control of their country and quit letting Islamo-fascist radicals dictate foreign policy.....

Answer 4

Ofcourse it's not. Devil lives in Israel! Actually, they have this crazy belief that this land is theirs, even though their messiah hasn't come yet and they cannot claim it as their land until he comes. So technically, they shouldn't even be there. The only reason they're still alive is because the US backs them up. Otherwise, the germans or the arabs would have wiped them off the face of this earth. They're horrible people. They bombed hospitals, escape roads, airports, bus stations. They bombed civilians trying to escape in cars and busses, and they bombed a PREDESIGNATED UN PEACEKEEPING LOOKOUT! All that over two soldiers? Yes, I must admit that Hezb-allah is retaliating, but what would you do if bombs are being dropped over your head. You'd fight back any way you can.

See the images :
http://www.fromisrael2lebanon.info
http://fromisraeltolebanon.info

And the article :
http://www.inminds.co.uk/from-beirut-to-jerusalem.html

Answer 5

As long as Lebanon breeds, feeds, supports, and houses Hezbollah terrorists, yes.... Lebanon accepts Hezbollah, so Lebanon is responsible also for what has happened. It is up to Lebanon, evict the terrorists(Hezbollah), shun Syrian and Iranian interference, stop supporting those who attack Israel. It is up to Lebanon and its people to end this war, if they can stop Hezbollah instead of blindly supporting that rat infested group of swine.

Answer 6

Of course it isn't fair. It isn't Lebanon's fault, really. But logic never seems to matter to the neo-cons/hawks in Israel or the US.

Answer 7

They are doing just what America 'has' done