why N.Y it's called the big Apple wouldn't be California?

Question

don't you think I'm right

every time I buy apples it says California.

Answer 1

i dont understand the question

Answer 2

NY History & Facts

Last Updated: Jul 20th, 2006 - 15:55:30


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Why New York is Called "The Big Apple"
By Sarah Lane
Jul 6, 2006, 11:28 PST









Why Is New York City Called “The Big Apple?”

If you were to visit the corner of West 54th Street and Broadway in New York City, you would be at “Big Apple Corner.” That is because the man who coined the phrase, “The Big Apple”, John Fitzgerald, lived there for 30 years.

During the 1920’s, Fitzgerald wrote a horse-racing column for the New York Morning Telegraph called “Around the Big Apple.” In 1924, Fitzgerald wrote that he first heard the term from stable hands in New Orleans who referred to New York racetracks as “The Big Apple,” or the ultimate goal of every horse trainer and jockey in the racing world. “Apple” referred to the prize being awarded for each race.

For a long time the phrase was thought to have originated in the 1930’s by jazz musicians, because of the old saying “There are many apples on the tree of success, but when you pick New York City, you pick the Big Apple.” Everyone wanted to perform in Harlem, the jazz capital of the world. But the above paragraph clearly shows that Fitzgerald used the phrase almost a decade earlier.

Barry Popik, a New York slang historian, was bound and determined to convince the New York City Government to officially recognize sportswriter John Fitzpatrick as the first to use the phrase. He finally succeeded in 1997. Hence the designated “Big Apple Corner.”

In 1971, the term “Big Apple” was adopted as the official advertising slogan of New York City, aimed at encouraging tourists to overlook its doom and gloom reputation in favor of the excitement and allure the city offered. The symbol of a big red apple was used to evoke a cheery image.

Source: Word Detective, NYC & Co.

Answer 3

The New York jazz scene in the 30s and 40s spawned the term Big Apple.
Since apples are grown in NY and in Washington state, why California? Wouldn't it be the big Orange?

Answer 4

NYC is the Big Apple because, like an apple that's been left out too long, it's rotten to the core. I didn't make that up; a famous New Yorker did (but I forget which one).

I've heard LA referred to as the Big Avocado and Atlanta as the Big Peach. Theoretically, Detroit could be the Big Lemon (kudos to you if you understand why).

Answer 5

New York City - The "Big Apple".
New York State - The "Empire State".
California - The "Golden State".

Answer 6

California is the big nut. Or maybe the big grape (for wine). I guess Florida is the big orange. What's Texas? A melon? Iowa is the big potatoe? Hawaii the big pineapple? (I hear that Hawaii dosn't grow pineapples anymore...so maybe a coconut?) Anyone want to go on with this?

Answer 7

Well it was going for the big cheese but wisconsin took that one

Answer 8

hi , i agreewith you ,, cali4nia should be the1 call the big apple not ny,, mm, good question , eh ,,

Answer 9

hm... i cali, i thought we'd be called the big grape or something...

Answer 10

no you JERK...were the GOLDEN STATE...you can keep the ROTTEN APPLE....