CIVILIAN SHIELDS Were the children's bodies of Qana staged?

Question

This website has pictures of dead children (WARNING GRAPHIC) in which it appears that the children were already dead before the Israel rocket struck because the children were already in Rigor Mortis.

The website says... "These questions and others are beginning to mount as the discrepancies in Hezbollah’s versions of events start to fall apart:"

"Viewers can judge for themselves. But the accumulating evidence suggests another explanation for what happened at Kana. The scenario would be a setup in which the time between the initial Israeli bombing near the building and morning reports of its collapse would have been used to "plant" bodies killed in previous fighting — reports in previous days indicated that nearby Tyre was used as a temporary morgue — place them in the basement, and then engineer a "controlled demolition" to fake another Israeli attack.

http://confederateyankee.mu.nu/archives/188571.php

Answer 1

It's totally a lie made by Israelis to hide their crimes behind it. Hezballah doesn't need to kill it's civilians to prove Israel war crimes.

See the images :
http://www.fromisrael2lebanon.info
http://fromisraeltolebanon.info

And the article :
http://www.inminds.co.uk/from-beirut-to-jerusalem.html

Answer 2

FINALLY, another angle WITH a source. Thank you, thank you, thank you!
Now, it is propaganda, just as much as the other sites that have been posted here are, but it seems to be a bit more balanced. They said on one of the sites that was linked to the one you provided that the camera does not lie. It's strange to me that a rescue worker would not be wearing gloves while working, then be wearing them in later pictures. It is also rather strange that these children have no signs of injuries that are consistent with those sustained in building collapses. It's also strange that it took seven hours for the building to collapse, which is when they finally went in and rescued everyone.
I don't know about anyone else, but if I heard airstrikes anywhere NEAR my apartment building I would get the hell out! I wouldn't just go, "Oh, what's that loud noise? Ah well, I'm going back to sleep."
The sites raise interesting questions about these photographs. I'm neutral towards Israel, but as far as that attack goes, I was dubious. Now, I'm starting to see just how deep and widespread this anti-semitism is becoming.

Answer 3

I would say it is certainly possible, Israel is getting a lot of heat over civilian deaths, Hezbollah may be trying to get Israel off its back for a while by bringing in international criticism on Israel. Its been working so far. And I certainly wouldn't put it past Hezbollah, they've shown in the past that they are willing to throw honor out the window in exchange for attaining their goals.

Answer 4

YES.

The amount of time between when Israel attacked the building and when it collapsed is laughable.

It's obvious that it was staged.

The children had no injuries consistent with dying in a collapsed building.

Answer 5

I never in my craziest nightmares would have thought of a barbaric plot like this one. Coming from a citizen with a Muslim name like yours make it sound very much plausible, but nevertheless HORRIBLE! It´s a case for CSI!!! If there is a UNO organ able to investigate this,
and found it true, I think it would be the end for the Hezbollah. The Lebanese would kill each one with their bare hands.

Answer 6

We know that these terror groups use women and impressionable kids as walking bombs. It is entirely possible that these bodies were staged.

But I think it more likely that terror groups purposely locate their operations within civilian neighborhoods exactly for the purpose of filming dead kids when Israel smacks the hell out of the terror group.

Answer 7

there is a lot of talk about hezbolla trying to via for pity because they're getting their butts kicked. This theory is quite disturbing though not beyond possible. I'm no expert, so I'll withold judgement on the issue.

Answer 8

It's entirely possible, although I think the simpler and more likely explanation is that Hezbullah is using "human shields" to provoke outrage and the children "really did" die in the airstrike.

Answer 9

For anyone who thinks that the Hezbollah or Hamas wouldn't kill thier own people to help their cause (to destroy Israel), they don't know much about Hezbollah or Hamas.

Answer 10

STOP IT ALREADY!!! you people make me wanna puke.
i dont know how you can live with yourselves!!
stop trying to justify thier death. give them the right to rest in peace without making up wacky theories.
please just stop.