Terrorists Responsible for the Bombing in Qana, not Israel?

Question

I wrote a college paper on a similar incident that happened in 1996 in Qana ... funny how history repeats itself. Yesterday israel released an infrared tape showing how Hezbollah launches missiles on top of or close to apartment buildings without regard for the innocent people inside. One of the rules of modern warfare is that if a missile is launched at you, you destroy the missile site or artillery piece. By placing artillery pieces next to schools and apartment buildings Hezbollah is playing with the lives of innocent civilians. Israel is not to blame for what happened yesterday. Funny how Israel shows more remorse for the death of civilians than Hezbollah. Terrorists by their very nature are cold-blooded killers with no regard for human life. Placing artillery guns on top of apartment buildings knowing that Israel will respond is a sick strategy of warfare that only a heartless killer would use.

Answer 1

Since it was found that hezbollah blew up the building 7 hrs after isreal bombed the area, the lebanese are use to hezbollahs tactics and no it hasnt changed, internationally people are realizing finally as before hezbollah is willing to kill there pawns and blame it on isreal to stir the international waters.....Those woman and children were sacrificed by hezbollah to win support, its funny how things backfire......... Thank you for seeing this as well, at least some people do research............

Answer 2

I agree with some of this ranting. On the other hand. How do you know that it was not the USA, CIA who kidnapped the Israel service men. The CIA could also be behind the so called "Hezbollah" terrorist acts.
We would not know but we do know that the CIA has a long history of telling lies. Our own Government also has a long history of lies.
Time will tell since the truth always finds out the liar.
American Tax payers send Israel about $2 billion a month, they have the best weapons in the world. Why is it that Israel can not take out the in coming missiles with our Patriot Anti-Missile systems which we gave to Israel?
BTW, are you aware that "Guerrilla warfare" can not be won, we as a nation seem to have not learned anything from the loss of 58,000 in Viet-Nam.

Answer 3

That is such twisted logic. Anybody who tries to take sides in this war is an idiot. None of the killers is innocent and they all have a bunch of reasons for why their killing is ok but the other side's is not. Logic like yours allows for a lot of killing but not much else. It is all rationalization and it is total and complete BS. If you also want the truth drones were flying around those buildings for days and must have known all those refugees were there. It sounds like revenge to me. Both sides are so caught up in revenge and their own innocence. And almost everybody is lying. It is pathetic. Don't think for a second that either side is innocent. None of them are. There are innocents caught up in all of this. That is the tragedy. The other part of the tragedy is that many many new militants were created today. Probably some of them so young that we see their revenge for many years (i.e. when they grow up). Those militants will get to face off against the people who have been victims of suicide bombings in Israel and the party will keep on going. Everybody will keep saying it's not their fault and we have no choice. Also, I have too say that I take serious issue with words like collateral damage, unavoidable and rules of war. It is a lot of B.S. thought up by people who are trying to justify the unjustifiable. Trust me, the collateral damagees don't see it as unavoidable.

Answer 4

Of course...Hezbollah destroyed the building and drop the bomb and killed the civilians...PLSSSSSSSS...Israel it's responsible and now,when everyone says they should stop those kind of attacks, they blame it on Hezbollah...
They should have stoped fire for 48 hours ,so UN could investigate what happened in Qana...5 min after they said they will cease fire for 48 hours bombs started falling in Lebanon again...What is Israel afraid the investigators will find there?
And trust me Israel shows absolutely no remorse for killing those civilians...

Answer 5

I am just sick and tiered of people announcing themselves as experts and talking on behalf of the Lebanese people . I have been there I have smelled the blood of the children dead under my feet so don't you tell me that "Israel "is not responsible you watch the all American media who doesn’t even tell half the truth when those people died yesterday the CNN said that over 50 people DIED not Killed as if they caught some kind of a virus and died. no they were killed by the hands of Israelis and the weapons they used are called smart bombs that the US gave , And FYI Hezbollah doesn’t shoot from above the building of civilians and if you don't believe me why won't you come here and help us burry those children who haven’t had the chance of living because people like you believe the lies the "Israelis" are saying and just blame other people for it.nd as for history repeating it self you are right another year another massacre and many more people beliving the same old lies
OK lets review the facts surrounding "Israel"actions.They have been occupying other people land calling it their own for over 50 years , through that time they have been killing women and children who have no means to protect themselves, the shot old men while there were praying so many times , they have declined to carry on the Nations council's decisions because there are above the international law, they have declined to carry on the orders on International court to remove the wall because again there are above all laws , and that is just in Palestine as fr Lebanon they have committed mascaras in Lebanon many times like in 1982 and in the first Qana massacre in 1993 when over 109 people were killed all women and children and the destroying of Lebanon infrastructure many time the latest were in 1996 and now in 2006 . they are occupying Lebanese land and again they are above the law and they can use band weapons like Smart booms to insure killing as many innocent children as possible and I can't wait to hear there last excuse for killing over 60 people half of them were children in Qana yesterday . So you tell me who is the devil?

Answer 6

wat u didnt know is that there is a hill in front of that apartment block that prevents people from shooting missiles beause they wont be able to see anything. Also they showed an empty building on the outskirts of qana. In 1996 hizballah werent shooting missiles and they hit a UN shelter. Yeah im lebanese and i dispised hizballah till this year when they decided to disarm after ur beloved israel gives lebanon its land back. After i saw that hizballah killed so many israelis and kicked them out of Bint Jbeil i fully support them.

Answer 7

Yes, a similar "massacre by Israel" happened 10 years ago there.

The Qana affair is very fishy. It certainly wouldn't be the first time Muslim cultists have "martyred" their own people in this way.

Answer 8

So the truth is finally coming out. Good to see that there are still people with common sense who refuse to rely on biased websites for their information.
Unfortunately, you are still going to be attacked for this question. The trend right now is to hate Bush AND Israel. You have to hate both, especially if you want to post on Y!A. It is in the unwritten rules.

Answer 9

I think it was the Boy Scout troop out of Ames, Iowa responsible for the bombing; not the Israelis. Never the Israelis.

Answer 10

nicely ethicly and in accordance to the Geneva convention, No. you're no longer "meant" to objective any civilians, civilian homes if possible, or hospitals. despite if, if it bring about an entire scale conflict, and Iran gained.. Then they'd be high quality. because of fact the winner tries the loser for conflict Crimes, no longer vice versa