Is '2001, a space oddysey' the only film to accurately show that there is no noise in space?

Question

All other Sci-Fi films have noise associated with explosions, gun fire, engines starting up etc. There is no noise in a vaccuum and as far as I know only 2001 has ever represented this accurately.

Answer 1

The classic film "2001, A Space Odyssey", "Moon Zero Two", a laughably awful "space Western" with James Saxon, and "Destination Moon", made in 1950, are recognised as the only three films to properly show the vacuum of space as being totally silent. That piece of shytte "2010 : The Year We Insult Kubrick's Memory" showed space as being full of sound, most notably when the Discovery was destroyed.

Answer 2

Can't think of another movie. However, in the new Battlestar Galatica, I don't think I've ever heard engine noise in the space scene. They've usually replaced it with drum music. When the show is focused in on a pilot, you can hear the background engine noise, but that's presumably because you're hearing what's going on inside the cockpit.

Answer 3

Radio waves are electromagnetic ability, the comparable as gentle. The earth's atmosphere absorbs and diffracts distinctive frequencies (think of colors) in distinctive strategies. area communications usually works on VHF, UHF or Microwave frequencies. The small wavelength of those ability it is obtainable to make intense benefit antennas at sensible sizes - think of of television aerials and Sat television dishes. those artwork with radio in an identical thank you to a reflector telescope with gentle, the curved floor focusing or concentrating a vulnerable sign to a element or sending it out like a spotlight beam. The monster dish antenna used via area floor stations boost the incoming alerts via actually tens of millions of cases. the different huge difference between floor and area communications is that there is not any longer something interior the way - the Earth's atmosphere thins out today over some miles upwards, then there is not any longer something to take up the sign, it is fairly 'Line of Sight' it is obtainable to talk with an area craft in low Earth orbit using walkie talkie form radios - countless the gap Station astronauts have had beginner (Ham) Radio licences, and characteristic instructions speaking to different Amateurs on the floor. i've got executed it with in basic terms a handheld VHF radio. The satellite tv for pc television device works using satellites in intense 'synchronous' orbits, approximately 25,000 miles up. The transmitters are fairly low ability (many times 50W if I undergo in recommendations top), yet could be gained on the floor with in basic terms a small dish aerial. the comparable frequency and ability in the international might have a usable variety of in basic terms some miles, with the aid of air absorption, obstructions and the curvature of the Earth's floor. different ability are used jointly with slender-band alerts that are extra handy to recover from history noise, plus innovations like forward errors Correction that permit a sign to be decoded even whilst the innovations is corrupted or 'broken'.

Answer 4

The TV series Firefly had an absence of sound in the space exterior scenes. I can't recall, but I'm sure they must have done the same thing in the film version, Serenity.

Answer 5

That was such an awsome movie! But I think you are wrong in saying that it is the only one to convey that space holds no soundwaves. How about 2010: The Year We Made Contact?

Answer 6

The other one I know is Serenity - there is only sound when the ships are within a planets atmosphere. When they are out in deep space, it's silent.

Answer 7

I think so. In 2010 we heard the sound of the engines firing.

Answer 8

Templejohn .. that movie is called "Silent Running" ... but it does not qualify as a correct answer to the current question.

Answer 9

How about "A voyage to the moon" by the Lumiere Brothers? Course, it was a silent movie....

Answer 10

There,s another one , starring Bruce dern, and three , droids, called Huey, Luey, and, DEWY.. CANT THINK WHAT ITS CALLED ???