If someone has an accent when they speak, why can't we hear it when they sing?

Question

Justin Hayward of the Moody Blues is from England and has an accent yet when he sings, you can't detect it Why

Answer 1

Because people are taught to enunciate properly when they sing. Singers are usually sticklers about it although there are singers that you can hear an accent when they sing.

Answer 2

The Beatles said that it sells better. (-:

Most of the time it's because the older artists (e.g. Moody Blues, Beatles) were emulating their musical heroes, such as Buddy Holly or Elvis Presley, who were Americans.

Listen to Phil Collins or The Clash and you'll hear a more pronounced accent. These guys are the next generation and had a wider array of bands to emulate.

Answer 3

have you ever listened to any of the early songs of the beatles or the solo songs of john lennon if you pay close attention you will hear a definitely hear a truly british accent the same is true for pink floyd and rod stewartother types of music are differently eorded so that the accent is not as noticiablei think a lot also depends on the style of musicalso how loud it is. like the rolling stones.or queen

Answer 4

the most obtrusive answer is that the song is discovered, a similar way the language is - phonetically. in case you hear the be conscious Dawg, you'll repeat the be conscious Dawg, while a reading of the be conscious may produce a spoken be conscious in the route of dug, or perhaps dorg. (depending upon one's "regularly occurring" pronunciation of that 3 letter blend) options you that's purely genuine even as making a song songs written outdoors your own coloqial lingistic community. be conscious that the Beatles sang in a decedly British accent even as making a song songs they wrote. And Selena had an obtrusive latin sound. that is likewise truly puzzling to shake tougher accents alongside with those of Asian international places, for instance, William Hung. for sure, you won't be able to low priced the impression of the song itself upon the singer. "Danny Boy," whose lyrics were written in England, by a Brit, who in accordance to all data had spent little time in eire, if he were in any respect, is very nearly continuously sang with an Irish Brog. in fact, a wise singer who needs to look to be a good singer will remodel the song to in good structure his or her own accent. If i'd use an party from this season's "American Idol," did you hear David prepare dinner's remix of a Dolly Parton song? David knows he won't be able to sing us of a, and rewrote the song for that reason. he's actual one among the least versatile singer on the prepare yet he's sensible sufficient that the common listener can't understand this - a minimum of it is what he seems banking on. besides i wish this helps which includes your question.

Answer 5

i think a big part of it is for commericalization purposes. to make it more appealing for americans, who account a major source of the world's consumers in any type of music. americans might not connect with a singer with a heavy british accent as they would with a singer without an obvious accent.

great examples of british singers who dont sound british and were very successful in the USA are the Beatles (of course), Thom Yorke of Radiohead, and Oasis.
A number of similar artists sing in obvious accents and have been less successful in the states such as damon albarn of Blur (especially the song 'Parklife') and Ray and Dave Davies of the Kinks (especially their early stuff).

Answer 6

The Beatles.

Answer 7

not sure but i have noticed that an artist with a accent when they talk don't have an accent when they sing too! i don't really know the answer.

Answer 8

There is something about singing that changes things.

I knew a guy who had a terrible stutter, but when he sang, it went away. very odd.