If I tell my commanding officer, I will not fight an unjust war that does not protect the citizens of America?

Question

Does this make me a patriot or am I committing treason?

Answer 1

Honey, this makes you a conscientious objector. It in no way makes you an enemy of the state, nor are you committing treason. Good luck. Their are many sites that you can go to about soldiers who feel the same way that you do.

Answer 2

Assuming that you are in the military it makes you a diserter. Expect a dishonorable discharge.

Assuming you are not in the military, it makes you a consciencious objector. It is not treason unless you take sides against the government, and by that I mean arms.

Assuming you are somewhere in the middle, get those consciencious objector documents into the hand of your reserve office before you get called up or you will be back to being a disserter.

And no you are not a patriot. To be a patriot you do in fact have to be willing to fight for your country. That does not mean you have to fight for it's leaders, but; it does mean you have to fight, and if you fight against the government and lose, you will definitely be treated as a traitor guilty of treason.

Just think, if we had lost the American Revolution, everyone on our side of the war could have been shot for treason.

So, tread lightly and becareful in how you speak about this.

Answer 3

Since there is no draft each person in the military volunteered. In the services you don't get a choice of which war to support. You know the day you enlist that you give up some rights for the sake of military discipline. If you disobey a lawful order, I don't think you are in any way protecting the citizens of America.

If the order is unlawful, then you have an obligation to disobey. You also have to be willing to go to the brig and pay the consequences.

Answer 4

You would be no Patriot (Patriot-supporter of own country: a proud supporter or defender of his or her country and its way of life.Encarta® World English Dictionary, North American Edition )

Treason: betrayal of country: a violation of the allegiance owed by somebody to his or her own country, e.g. by aiding an enemy
(Encarta® World English Dictionary, North American Edition )

If we were to go by definitions you are closer to committing treason, however I would never support your decision and opinion, committing treason for something you truly believe in is not necessarily a bad thing...though your country and your people will condemn you, I prefer to die for what I believe than to live an unhappy lie. Think about it, if it's worth it and what you truly want, take the shot. If it's just an opinion not based on fact or truly convinced of it...rethink the situation.

Also remember the declaration of independence of the US was a cause charged with treason.

Answer 5

of path. The invoice of Rights exchange into enacted in a time while a properly-prepared protection rigidity wasn't drastically much less effectual than a countrywide protection rigidity of similar length. The innovative conflict, even with each and everything, exchange into fought frequently between a protection rigidity and an imperial military, with the protection rigidity popping out triumphant. the 2d modification secure the skill of the type of protection rigidity to type returned, could the will upward push up. however the Founders did no longer assume the form of conflict machines able to killing tens of millions with the frenzy of a button, and costing extra effective than the existence earning of hundreds of conventional human beings apiece. there exchange into no Colonial-era corresponding to an F-15, or a nuclear submarine, or an ICBM - and not even the main ardent "good to undergo palms" form thinks that persons could be waiting to purchase and administration those issues. So the 2d modification has surely fallen from an substantial component to our device of checks and balances to an rather formalized risk-free practices of looking and taking photos hobbyists, truthfully Constitutionally preserving your good to bag some game on the weekend or shop a Glock on your nightstand to experience annoying. this is no longer useful interior the comparable way it exchange into written to be. That being reported, the well-liked argument is, could we be eagerly snuffing out anybody rights that are actually not substantial interior the comparable way they was once? could our default place on guy or woman freedom be, "if this is no longer considered mandatory to the operation of the government, we could continually have as few freedoms as a possibility?"

Answer 6

Is this a hypothetical question?
Stand by your convictions.
Gonna cost you court martial probably.
A less then honorable discharge most likely.
Stand a chance of time in brig or stockade.

What to you consider fighting?
Grunt?
Or working on flight deck of aircraft carrier loading ordinance on aircraft?
Isn't the end result the same?
But this has got to be hypothetical question.
Cause if you were really military you would not have to come to Yahoo Answers for advise.
You would have consulted with the barracks lawyer.
Claiming conscientious objector gonna make you look phony.

But to answer your question it will make you look like a coward if you don't stick to your convictions and take whatever consequences arise from your decision.

Answer 7

Neither. But if you blow off the oath you made at enlistment to obey the orders of the officers appointed over you, expect to face discipline in accordance with the Uniform Code of Military Justice. If while serving you want to apply for conscientious objector status, there are ways to go about it without "refusing" anything. If you wait until you're in combat - it will be desertion and you're in big trubs.

Answer 8

Maybe not treason, but if you leave your post, depending upon where that post is, it can be considered desertion not just AWOL or UA. Also, if you didn't want to fight when told to fight, why did you sign the dotted line? If your answer is "for the college money" just shoot yourself in the foot and get out now....your unit will greatly appreciate it.

Answer 9

It's not treason if you don't go AWOL..You will be sent to Leavenworth for a minute, but will stay alive. You can use your Religious convictions like the chicken hawk Republicans that wont even enlist.

Answer 10

Does the word "Stockade" mean anything to you?

If you are in the military, you don't get to pick and choose your assignments. You would be in violation of the Uniform Code of Military Justice, Article 92, failure to obey order or regulation, at least.