Who would WIn in a Fight?

Question

Who would win in a fight Rogue or The Incredible Hulk??
My boyfriend and I have been debating this. He thinks that the Hulk could get mad enough and overpower Rogue's touch, I say Rogue would win since she drains powers. Best answer wins!!

Answer 1

Whoever makes first contact wins. If Hulk can land a punch without contacting her skin, Rogue would be squished; even if he contacts skin, the momentum alone should be enough to wipe her out. OTOH if Rogue can land a touch, she will not only drain his strength but knock him unconscious. Given that Rogue can fly (last time I checked) and is far more agile, I'd put my money on her.

Answer 2

it is kind of uncertain. Rogue can fly and can drain powers while hulk's power is endless. i mean hulk is probably stronger but if weakened enough he could turn into Bruce Banner, and then rogue would win. Draining his powers would be a mistake cause while most of the powers she drains are not permanent, gamma based features may be, and then she would be driven mad by the radiation and probably develop a hulk side of her own. So we probably need a comic written on this subject to see who wins.

Answer 3

in this instance Rogue would win. Even if The hulk got one good potshot in, when rogue got her hands on him he would be immediately drained of his powers. So much so the he would not only be weakened, he would likely become Bruce Banner, leaving him indisputably the loser. As Bruce Banner he is a normal human being, and no human can resist Rogue's power. Rogue already has superstrength (in the comicbooks). And she can fly. She permanately absorbs the powers of those she drains to death. So not only would Rogue win, but she'd be a flying She- Hulk.

Answer 4

Hulk would have squeezed the life out of Rogue before she could drain his energy dry. Besides the more Rogue drains Hulk's energy the angrier Hulk gets and the stronger he gets.

Answer 5

All wrong.....the Hulks power is perhaps even too much for Rogue to handle. In order for her to even drain him she would have to get in close and The Hulk is too fast and too strong for her to withstand the punishment she would have to take to get a full drain to render him unconscious. Maybe she would drain a little bit but Hulk would regain it instantly. Also if he hits her her draining effect doesn't take effect right away. This was seen in an episode of x-men where Gambit kissed Rogue and the drain effect happened after a second or two. So, if Hulk lands one punch he would render her unconscious or even kill her. True winner.......Hulk.

Answer 6

Rougue's touch would absorb some of the power of the hulk, but that would only make him angrier. The hulk's strength grows exponentially the madder he gets. While rogue is strong, and she is neigh invulnerable to physical attacks, she wouldn't be able to stand toe-to-toe with the incredible hulk. Once ole-purple pants got pissed enough, it would just be a matter of catching rogue with one good, solid, gamma powered punch, and then it's lights out little miss mutant.

Answer 7

You are absolutely right, Hulk would have to touch Rogue and that would trip her powers. Not only would Rogue become Hulk-like, Hulk would lose powers and most likely become unconscious. Rogue is one tough woman!

Answer 8

The Hulk's dad died because he couldn't absorb all of Hulk's power. I guess Rogue would die too.

Answer 9

Hulk Smash!

Answer 10

The Incredible Hulk would dominate anyone in the Marvel universe unless they could destroy the planet or use psychic powers. He's too strong. He'd either smash her up before she got the chance or she'd go crazy trying to take his power.