Government. Can it be perfect?

Question

Is there such thing as a perfect government....Over the years philosophers and thinkers have challenged this question...whats your input??

Answer 1

No, for one Gov'ts are ran by people, and no one is perfect.

Second perfection is subjective. ever person has his or her own definition of perfection. often those definitions conflict with other's definition.

Third for government to be perfect would have to mean that all people are happy with the rules and regulations that they fall under. See second point and you know why this is not possible. Also the fact that there would have to be a major consensus of all the people that fall under the government of discussion. This would be virtually impossible to achieve. However to achieve it would mean eliminating any and all decension, and not allowing differing view points. That means we are back into the time of Jesus Christ and before.

The only "perfect government" is that of animals. Take a pack of dogs for example, there are certain rules that are accepted by all of the dogs for determining the leaders of the pack, who eats first, who hunts, etc. Once the authorities in the pack are determined rarely is the authority disputed. Since people are not animals, this cannot be achieved.

there will always be differing opinions and someone to challenge authority.

Answer 2

The most perfect government is an imperfect government-

People have such a broad range of political issues that no single government can accommodate everyone's needs. The instant Republicans start griping about tax hikes, there is a big homeless surge because welfare programs are cut! The instant that Democrats reform health care, health insurance companies go bankrupt because they are no longer necessary!

There is an old adage that says that you can't please everyone.

Even though Republicans and Democrats are always pissed at each other, it actually drives political systems and economies towards compromise and advancement!

Just my two cents.

Answer 3

A government cannot be perfect. Nothing is perfect. Governments can be corrupt, have bad leaders, not every one gets fair treatment, governments can be overthrown so governments are not perfect. If governments were perfect, everyone would be treated fair, there would be no bad leaders, there would be no corruption in the government, and everyone would have justice.

Answer 4

Your gadget has a similar center flaw that kills Communism (do not mixture that up with actual Socialism. Your talking of Marxist Socialism it truly is fairly Communism with a prettier call). That flaw is that any gadget that mistrust's it is own human beings is doomed to oppress those human beings. it fairly is why Democracy flourished. even as Democratic international locations nonetheless held the benifit of the human beings and relied on their own human beings, those human beings's flourished. even as Democracy has it is flaws, it is center works. it fairly is the believe of the human beings. Leveling human beings is to mistrust human beings. To make all equivalent is to tear down human beings to the bottom trouble-free denominator. That itself is more effective evil to the human soul than some thing else which could be performed to someone. To field someone in. to reduce what they can do is poison to the human soul. The mistrust is likewise poison to the human spirit. it fairly is why Communism fails. it truly is inheriently an oppressive gadget. Your gadget might want to fail a similar way. it might want to oppress human beings. cause them to below human. For an party imagine about enforcement of the letter of the regulation vrs the spirit of a regulation. no rely how sturdy the regulation is, blind enforcement creates as a lot or more effective injustice than the regulation changed into written to avert. A device no matter if it is a human device which incorporates Marxist sort Socialism or actually a machine can not interpet the spirit of a regulation. it may purely implement the letter of it. As such the regulation will develop into meaningless. As a sensible guy once suggested "the purely actual regulation is one which leads to freedom." Enforcement of the letter of any regulation leads far flung from freedom and could develop into an invalid regulation. a device of oppression. A manipulation of the human spirit.

Answer 5

Oh, yes, ever so perfect.
A government of the cyphercube, by the cyphercube, and most of all for the cyphercube.
Perfection, at long last.

Answer 6

That would be asking if a human can be perfect. There's no such thing.

Answer 7

No-- Government is made of people with different ideologies, faults, greed, ideas etc. etc. All those have imperfections so by definition there can't be a perfect government.

Answer 8

No becuz in any Government, people will still be pissed off no matter what anything from so called racism to unkown crap.

Answer 9

No, Humans by nature are imperfect. So governments can never be.

Answer 10

hell no! government sucks. it can never be perfect. trust me, i work for the bastards