Muhammad was born in AD 571 so how come Jews can't live in their ancestral homeland that is 5,000 years old?

Answer 1

Beats me. What I want to know is who the hell are the Palestinians? When the Jews were crossing the desert to escape the Pharoah, there was no such thing as a Palestinian. Where the hell did they pop up from, that they can claim someone else's territory as their homeland?

Answer 2

I will tell you why, if everyone was able to take over there ancestral land, Then the Native Americans would be coming and knocking on your door at any minute. Israel was established after world war 2 as a safe haven for Jewish people to ensure that the atrocities that occured during the war would not happen again. The territory at the time was controlled by Britain and was inhabited by Palestinian people. The Jewish people were originally offered a territory somewhere in Africa but the a movement started called the "Zionist movement" began and they demanded that the country now known as Israel be located in on the holy lands. The British government was under alot of pressure during this period and basically promised the land to both the Jewish people and the Palestinians and when they withdrew from the lands a war broke out that has lasted from the British withdrawl until present day....

Try Reading "From Beirut to Jerusalem"
this is a very good book written by an American Journalist who has studied the Middle East politics for most of his life.

Answer 3

The answer to that lies in the study of the history of the Jews and the region you're asking about. There's a thing called property rights. This is at the heart of the problem and the modern problem began when the Allies gave the Jews a parcel of land now known as Israel at the end of WWII.

Answer 4

The Arab Socialist Party, the BAATH Party, is the basis of all government in Jordan, Syria, and Iran, and was the party of Iraq. Saddam Hussein is the current world president.

The Baath Party was formed as a coalition of 7 Arab Socialist Parties in 1930, under the Grand Mufti, and follows the Arabic translation of Mein Kampf, by Adolf Hitler.

The current terrorist movement is simply a continuation of the pogrom to exterminate the Jews, by Adolf Hitler's Nazi Party, now run by the Arab Socialist Party (actually very closely modeled after Nazism!).

And, there is one more thing you need to realize. The Arabs of the Baath Party in the 1930's, planned to rule the world, either side of he Equator, and continously around the globe , within the next century!

The mantra of the Arab Nazi's is very similar to that of the Muslim, 1. to tax the foreigner, 2. to convert the foreigner or unbeliever, and 3. to kill those who don't convert, and take all of their property. These plans parallel those of the Nazi Party of World War II.

Answer 5

well first off, to say it is their ancestal home of 5000 years is incorrect seeing as how the jews have only existed for less than 2k years since their exodus from egypt. the problem arises from the fact they both lay claim to the land through a religious promise. the jews are the decendants of abraham through his legitimate son with his wife. the muslims are decendant of abraham through his illegitimate son from his wife's handmaiden, that is if you believe in what the two religion's holy books state. so the both claim god promised the land to them. however the muslims as the ottoman empire invaded and conquered the lands that is now isreal along with a great many other lands, basically setting up all the arab nations at this point. at one time they even controlled parts of europe until the crusades which pushed them out and eventually moved into jerusalem. so as long as both groups maintain a strong belief in their religion this issue will never be solved, that or until one group is wiped off the planet.

Answer 6

Who told u that Prophet Muhammed was the first Arab man ever to live on earth?!!! Arabs are 6000 years old!!! And they have always lived there, in Palestine!!!! Go back to school, please, but stay awake this time! The same advise is also offered to the person who posted the first answer! She is more illiterate than you!!!!
Are all Americans so superficial and ignorant? I think not, but the majority are!! How come ur country is governing the world while u have people as idiotic as u two?!!!!!!

Answer 7

Palestinians lived in the holy land before the Arabs and Jews Zionists and racists claim that the Ancient Jews who lived in the Holy Land 3000 years were their ancestors while they deny the contemporary Palestinian people the right to claim their antecessors the Ancient Palestinian People
Palestine was the name of the Holy Land from the Roman time up to now. and look ALL MEN ARE CREATED EQUAL BYGOD
The HOLY LAND IS FOR ALL GOD PEOPLE JEWS [sph +shik} AND PALESTINIAN CHIRSTIAN AND MUSLEMS

.

Answer 8

Israel is just an excuse for Muslim Extremists who refuse to tolerate anyone, even other Muslims who don't agree with their fanatical beliefs. The proof is the number of different people in different countries around the world whom they are killing. They are killing people in America, Israel, Iraq, England, Spain, Russia, India, Indonesia, The Philippines, and I just saw a report that they want to start a holy war in Africa. From that list it seems pretty obvious who the evil ones are.

Answer 9

More or less for the same reason that the Amerindians can't send all the Caucasians back to Europe today.

Realpolitik. It's the here-and-now that matters, for the most part. Possession is nine-tenths of the law, yada yada yada.

Answer 10

It goes back to the Isaac Ishmael debate.

Ishmael was born first but Isaac inherited his fathers domain.

Fast forward 5K years and the Arabs are still complaining about who's land it is.