HP fans. Who all here thinks that Sirius is going to make a comeback in book 7?

Question

...and what do you all think is behind the veil that was at the Department of Mysteries?

I personally don't think that he is, but I have a lot of friends that disagree.

As far as the veil, my guess is that it has something to do with the spirit world, sort of like an in-between; but I really haven't a clue.

Answer 1

Perhaps , as JK said the mirror in which he gave harry right before his demise will make a comeback maybe it can leave messages , harry never did fully try it out .

Sirius is dead , JK made him die in order for harry to truly feel the pain of death and for you to sympathize with harry , so I would say no he is not coming back . But that doesn't mean he'll be left out of the book .

I think the seventh book is largely going to revolve around Harry's search for answers and truth and I believe there is a large chunk of Sirius's life yet to be discovered ...mainly his brothers middle name , so I believe a trip to 12 grimmauld (sp?) place is in order , and of course while there Harry will stumble onto something Sirius left behind (the above mentioned mirror maybe ?)

But as someone already said all this is for the future and Rowling to decide for now we can only guess .

P.S I have no doubt what-so-ever that the vail does exactly as you said , its a portal between this life and the one after it , that why Sirius didnt have to be killed in order to die , and why luna and harry were both so aware of it (remember the two of them have already lost someone dear to them).

Answer 2

I'm under the impression that Sirius is, unfortunately, gone for good.

I sort of agree with you on the veil as well.

Only time will tell tho, eh?

Answer 3

I joined Y!A somewhat over 2 months after, the launch of "Deathly Hollows". The questions that were round on the time were usually about human beings's evaluations about the ending, which on the time i became satisfied to share it, considering i don't understand that a lot of human beings in actual existence who quite like Harry Potter. there became also so much better questions about the sequence in most circumstances on the prompt, it wasn't everyday for there to be 3 hp questions interior the front web page each and each and every time you clicked into "Books & Authors". It became large, yet then got here what I loved to call the "darkish era" it became usually some scattered questions about "the toddler ingredient" or about how Neville pulled were given the sword. i ended finding out "Books & Authors" and performed interest only to P&S. i tried to construct a community of HP followers so as that i doesn't bypass over any good questions, yet for alongside time there became a shortage. Now in spite of the indisputable fact that new and intensely curiously random questions have sprung up and, i love it. The what if questions, make each and each and every of the solutions interesting to study, and quite interesting to respond to in personality. :P

Answer 4

I guess not. Sirius is dead and with Jk trying to kill all of Harry's protectors there is no doubt that more of them will get killed. I do not think he would come back.

Answer 5

i kind of hope he will but who knows with jk rowling!
i thought the veil was a passage to the spirit world too, but whether you have to be dead or alive to have access is the question

Answer 6

sirius is dead. i think he will be able to communicate with harry somehow but i don't think he will come back to life. i agree with you about the veil.

Answer 7

I really do not thin he will make a comebakc but I do believe you will get to meet his brother that is supposed to be dead.

Answer 8

i think so...it would make the last book complete. I'm also betting that one of the main characters die....prob harry

Answer 9

hes dead, hes not gonna come back!