Who's bright idea was it to make a Jewish state smack in the middle of Muslim countries??

Question

We should have given the Jews Germany. I mean no disrespect to Jews by this question. Would Jews wanted there country in a place that would cause nothing but conflict and war?

God suposedly made the whole world and the whole universe for that matter. Why would "God" care about a small piece of realistate in the middle east?? This whole God and prophecy crap is bull and policy should not be made according to it!!

Answer 1

Corrections need to de made:

1/ Israel was created by Zionists in order to guarantee a "safe" haven for "Jews" who were being persecuted in Europe.

2/ Israel evolved into a geo-political and strategic country of vital importance to the West.

3/ The ONLY REAL JEWS, biblically speaking are the Sephardic or Oriental Jews. The so-called European Jews are not ethnically Jewish, but simply converted to Judaism and hail from the kingdom of Khazar in southern Russia. Therefore, if the Bible should be trusted, it does not apply to European Jews.

4/ Isreal or as many prefer to call it: The Holy Land, was not always under Jewish control. More often than not, Israel was under the control of foreign powers. As long as these powers existed, Jews and "others" lived in peace. Jews are the third governing religious group in the country following the Muslims and the Crusaders. Since the break-up of the Ottoman Empire, the Zionists felt that due to persecution of "Jews" in Europe, a safe haven was necessary. Now, why did these European Jews even believe that God gave them a right to claim a land inhabited by people already there, even more so since they are not the Biblical Jews????
Go figure....

Answer 2

Oh, man, I like your question! There is a lot of justice in it. The Germans did kill 6,000,000 Jews.

However, the Jews have an ancient claim on the land of Israel, since biblical times. The Jews used to live there, but they were banished and made refugees from their homeland.

Furthermore, Jews actual OWN a great deal of the land, because they paid for it. Even before the state of Israel was created, Arabs in the area sold pieces of land to the Jews.

So Jews have both a biblical and legal claim to the land.

Answer 3

It was theirs (the jews) ! Think about the question that you are asking .Whom in there right mind would wan't some peice of property in the middle of nowhere unless it had some "monetary" value?(i.e. oil reserves /or in approximatey too them) These people beleive that they are the chosen people of "god" & for this reason feel the need to control everything else .The best way to do this is through oil.
As far as giving the jews "Germany" .We then ,would have to give them every other country in Europe ! For the reason that Europe has awaken to the zionist way of doing things,so it would be atleast as bad as the situation is now! If by not far worse!!!!!

Answer 4

God's

God put Israel under probation for 2520 years since their exile from Babylon. Time is almost up and Israel again receives their land and whomever comes against it will be destroyed by God. Israel belong to them until they were taken into captivity into Babylon in 606 BC.
By the way Germany has made some restitution to the Jews and disarmed their nation because of what they did. It is called repentence, these terrorist groups are coming after you soon and then you will not make such uninformed remarks.

Answer 5

Sounds like you don't know that much (that's okay)

Here's the deal.

Jews have been living in present-day Israel for at least 5,000 years. Arabs were living in present-day Saudi Arabia as nomads and pagans.

Muhammad wasn't born until AD 571 (only 1400 years ago) in Mecca, Saudi Arabia.

Muhammad led armies that tried to take as much land as possible. Arabs were united under his flag of "Islam" which means "Submission".

Muslims took over Jewish holy sites like Hebron and destroyed the Jewish temple in Jerusalam and building mosques in their place.

After Nazis tried to wip out the Jews, many European Jews joined the Holy Land Jews and formed Israel so they would be left alone.

Muslims can't leave the Jews alone.

Answer 6

The Muslim countries you refer to are smack in the middle of the holy land. After world war II the world felt that the Jews needed there own country, what better place to put it than in the holy land. Germany wouldn't have worked because, despite what they tell us, Nazism and anti-Semitic feelings are still there.

Answer 7

in relation to sweeties' answer there is no such true origin for the people group Palestine. that word was FIRST used by the Romans's during their occupation of Israel. It was a general term used by the Romans for ALL NON-JEWISH people living in that area. It was a term the Romans's used to mock the Jewish people with the reference to the philistines which was a people group back in the old testament that NO LONGER exist. Palestine is not a true people group with a cohesive background or history. Please read your history before you go believing half trues

Answer 8

because the commercial revolution, mass media, colonization, democracy, an stronger center type, and many different blended causes have tailored and modernized western subculture (maximum folk of the Christian international locations with rules preserving the prepare of loose faith) to the point we are at now. do not fool your self we killed some distance more effective non-christians for no longer replacing then Jews or Muslims have killed for his or her religous ideals at this element in heritage. more effective than possibly your a Christian now because someone or numerous human beings on your ancestry were positioned to lack of existence for being heretics, possibly burned alive or beheaded. confident we've a much more effective liberal and open minded technique of religion at this element in time yet tens of millions died to get us to date. It changed into no longer that some time previous in heritage (some hundred years or so) that a Jew changed into safer to coach his faith in Muslim lands then he changed into in Christian. shall we no longer forget interior the 1940's and 50's Jews in Europe and the U.S. the position killed by using the tens of millions. you imagine thats plenty verify into what percentage Jews the Christians killed on their thanks to the Crusades. (no longer to tutor each and every of the Orthodox Christians and different non-roman catholics) ok we've rules preserving the prepare of religion yet seem at your question, it truly isn't any longer fairly a question, its the first step in route of enacting rules persecuting non-christians. rules start up as a theory interior the minds of the human beings. Now are not getting the incorrect impact i'm a Christian and under no circumstances unhappy about it yet i'm also honest with myself "for all have sinned and fallen short of the honour of God". Get off your severe horse.

Answer 9

Whose idea? The Muslims who gladly sold the land to Jewish folks away back a few hundred years ago.

Answer 10

God