I am trying to pick between Liverpool and Arsenal in the EPL. Feel guilty picking a winner, any alternatives?

Question

So, now that the World Cup is over I want to pick an Premiership team, but am having a trouble. I think I have narrowed it to Liverpool or Arsenal, but I feel guilty for picking teams clearly at the top of the competitive balance. Does anyone have good suggestions. I went to Indiana University so I understand rich tradition and I have been a Cubs fan all my life so I understand loosing.

Answer 1

you should pick LIVERPOOL..

i give u 10 reason why u choose LFC..

Ten reasons why Liverpool can win the Premiership

A not entirely unbiased appraisal of Liverpool's title prospects....

1) Rafa the Great Usurper

As with business, success in football is generally achieved from the top down and credit must go to Rick Parry for his shrewd acquisition of Benitez. At a time when many clubs in Spain dallied, Parry took action and got his man. Under appreciated outside of Valencia, Rafa was overlooked for the Real Madrid job, despite having been a former player and youth team coach at the Bernabeau, and his fantastic track record at Valencia. Even everyone’s favourite Spaniard, Guillem Balague, at the start of the 2002/2003 season, voiced his concerns that Benitez's Valencia did not have a proven goal-scorer on the books and contended that they would find it hard to compete with Real Madrid and Barcelona for the title. Undeterred Rafa moved Mista from midfield to up front and was rewarded with some 19 goals from his newly converted striker and Valencia went on to win the league despite Benitez being denied significant funds to strengthen his team. What does this tell us? Well if he can overhaul the Spanish giants without an established striker or a decent transfer budget, surely he can overtake the lowly Chelsea and Man Utd, given some funds and an established goal-scorer. Famously Rafa said of his struggles to get the Valencia board to sign his transfer targets “I asked for a bed-side table but they bought me a lamp”, his frustration at not being able to improve his team one of the main reasons for his departure. And boy did those Valencia fans cry when he left. If Rafa were still there you can bet you bottom dollar that Valencia would have pushed Barca all the way last season.

2) Gerrard par excellance

A world class player that is frequently the difference between us and them, regularly stepping up to score the crucial goal or turn a match. All title winning teams need at least one and our one is as good as any of the current crop. He outdid Kaka and Pirlo in Istanbul and generally outperforms anyone he’s up against.

3) Carragher and co.

Our defence is mean and getting meaner and is the basis of Rafa’s footballing philosophy and the platform for his success. Steve Finnan is so good you often don’t notice him in games. Riise under Rafa has shown none of his earlier defensive fallibilities. Hyppia – now defends better than ever without seeming to take more than three steps in any direction. Carragher – ask any player on the continent, especially Italians or Spaniards, about Carragher’s omission from the England starting eleven, and they would tell you that Sven is bonkers. Carra can win matches from the back. In my estimation he comes second only to Terry because of the latter’s goal contributions as the UK’s best defender and is easily top ten in the world. Reina – getting better and more dominant in the penalty box with every game, quick off the line, consistent, vocal, and an excellent shot stopper and distributor. In front of this is a well-oiled midfield that closes down as a team and is making it increasingly difficult for the opposition to get though, or even string a few passes together.

4) Alonso

The best ten million LFC ever spent. Young, classy, faultless, creative and one of the top three tackle makers in the league last season. His passing is a joy to behold and he can dominate games from a deep lying midfield position. Can anyone remember a player scoring from his own half with his weak foot before? Enough said.

5) The fans

Prawn sandwich anyone? Thought not. Anfield still has that old school vibe, unsullied by the corporate brigade and unlike Chelsea, Man Utd and Arsenal, capable of rousing a song before being 2-0 up, or when 3-0 down at half time in the Champions League final. We have the edge in terms of fan power over our nearest rivals.

6) Brazil’s first choice full-backs?

It’s an alluring notion. With the retirements of Cafu and Roberto Carlos we could quite feasibly soon be losing our full-backs to the samba cause on international duty. Although I don’t expect Rafa to have them rampaging up and down the wing like those two did for Brazil our attacking options from that position should be twice as good as last season. Providing Rafa can nail down a deal for Alves – who was the star of the show in Sevilla’s demolition of Middlesbrough during last season’s Uefa cup final.

7) Coaching

I don’t know what Rafa says to the players or does on the training pitch but from seeing the results on the pitch I know we have the edge over coaching and management teams at other clubs. Some of this credit must surely go to the background staff of Pako Ayestaran et al, who Craig Bellamy has praised since his arrival and who surely have played a crucial role in moulding us towards invincibility. When they were at Valencia as soon as they went one-nil up, which they invariably did, you knew the result was in the bag and so did the opposing teams.

I’m sure most of you will have heard that Rafa is not the molly-cuddling type. Carragher has said that Rafa doesn’t really talk to the players apart from footballing matters; no warm shoulders, or pandering to the temperamental mind-sets of the modern player. No “Hi, are you okay, do you want a cuddle, have you brushed your teeth” as I imagine Ferguson might say to Ronaldo, Rooney and Ferdinand. Gerrard’s near departure was, I think, a by-product of him feeling unwanted and unloved in the post-Houllier environment, Gerrard was used to being constantly assured and coaxed in a manner that Benitez does not subscribe to. But once they get used to it, the team and players reap the rewards of Benitez’s stoic manner.

To illustrate my point an interesting parallel can be drawn between Rafa’s methods and those of New Zealand’s All Blacks. After New Zealand underperformed at the Rugby World cup when England went on to win it, their coaches and governing bodies reviewed their methodology and training practices. What they decided was that the players had become over-coached. They were told when and how to do practically everything and all their needs were catered for and prearranged for their convenience. The downside of this they realised, was that players had forgotten how to think and act for themselves and the by product of this was that when their game-plan didn’t work, they were poor at adapting, improvising and taking matters in to their own hands on the pitch.

One only need look at the results in Istanbul and Cardiff when behind to Milan and West Ham respectively to see that the team now believe in themselves and look to each other to turn results around. This is a key aspect of Rafa’s management philosophy and I think it compares favourably to the overbearing styles of Mourinho and Ferguson.

8) Little and Large

The classic combination of a little man with pace and a big man with a good touch who can win knock-ons. The last time I can think of a pair like this was when Kevin Phillips and Niall Quinn linked up for Sunderland and the former won the golden boot. Can Crouchy supply a shed load of goals in a similar manner to Quinny for his vertically challenged partner in attack. You bet your **** he can. Crouch could hold up an Avalanche if need be and Bellamy got 17 goals in 27 starts last season in all competitions. If he, Gerrard and Crouch get an understanding going we could score as many goals as Arsenal, Chelsea or Man Utd next season and more than compete with them defensively.

9) Hunger: We're all starving for success

Our boys are hungry, none of them have a league winners medal to their names and champions league glory won’t have sated that hunger. In contrast the old guard at Man Utd, a fair chunk of the Arsenal and obviously most of Chelsea’s players might not be quite as champing at the bit for domestic glory as our boys, who must feel that their time is now. This belief and hunger could make the difference.

10) Wrecking ball

All the best and most successful teams need and have one. Think Makelele, Gattuso, dare I mention him Keane, Vieira during his Arsenal glory and Emerson at Juventus. The role is a demanding and increasingly key one in modern football. What Sissoko has over all of them, making up for deficiencies in his rapidly improving ball control, is his ability to run and run. When he leaves training he runs to his car, drives home, and then runs to the door, up the steps and in the bath. Or you might believe it such is his apparent love of running. He'd chase a paper bag in a hurricane and stomp on it for defying him. When Rafa signed him and stated that he could be better than Vieira I thought 'Yeah right' but although he can't match him for skill, passing and the ability to turn defence in to attack, yet, such is his defensive value and sheer hard graft that his contributions to the cause are beginning to approach the level that Vieira achieved for Arsenal.

Answer 2

1

Answer 3

I've been an Arsenal fan for 9 years so maybe you would like to go for it. "Teams clearly at the top of the competitive balance" would definitely mean teams like Chelsea, Man Utd, Liverpool and Arsenal. No doubt about it these 4 clubs are probably the only serious ones competing for the EPL title for as long as I could remember. But you might want to look at up-and-coming Tottenham (though they're our hated rivals) and giant-killers Bolton. They're holding on well despite not having the financial muscle of the above 4 teams (most notably Chelsea).

Answer 4

I'm in the same situation as you. Click on my ID to read a similar question i just asked. I got lots of great responses, i decided to definitly not pick any of the big 4 (chelsea, man u, arsenal, or liverpool) they are too good. Brits won't respect you if arbitrarily decide to support one of those teams. It would be like someone from europe trying to pick a baseball team to support and they pick the yankees, that would be so lame. you dont want to be that guy.

I recommend you start watching the season without a team and decide which team you enjoy watching the most. If you have fox soccer chanel you can get a lot of the games.

Answer 5

You say you understand Tradition? Well than Liverpool is the team for you than. Liverpool have more Tradition than any other club in the world. When they play a home game at Anfield and the Fan's sing "You Will Never Walk Alone" you will cry my mate. I have done so myself as a youngster. Liverpool are the Most Successful European team over the last 100 years. Champions of Europe 5 times and 18 league titles and we are the current FA Cup Holder's. Steven Gerrard has Supported Liverpool his whole life and now his Leading them. He play's with PRIDE and PASSION and he want's to win for the FAN'S cause he know's what it means to them. Rafa Benitez and Stevie Gerrard are bringing the Premier League Title to Merseyside this season.

Answer 6

I would like to tell you to go for Arsenal! They're my team, & have been so since years... The 2003-04 season was outstanding. They broke records throughout. Went the FULL season undefeated (only team to have ever done that in the Premier League). Extended the undefeated streak to 49 games (2002-2004) before finally losing to none other than Man-U.

That's not the way you go about it though... Why don't you watch a few matches of both teams & then decide who u prefer based on their playing styles, on-field sportsmanship, etc. instead of the users comments here? :)

Answer 7

Since you understand tradtion, you have to go with teh Kops of Liverpool, 5 time winner of Champions league, captained by Gerrard, the best player in England.
And you should stave off your losing streak with the Cubs and about time you joined a winner.
And moreover, when you become a fan of Liverpool, You'll never, ever walk alone....

Answer 8

Well, the obvious answer is Liverpool, for me, that is. If you like to watch people playing soccer with their hearts, then you should inevitably support Liverpool, because of their never-say-die attitude. Liverpool just goes on fighting on and on until the final whistle. It doesn't matter whether a win or a defeat.
However, if you like exciting, short passing soccer, then you just have to support Arsenal. Even if i'm a liverpool supporter, i just reallly like Arsenal's style of play. When they play as one, it's just really fantastic to see football as it should be played: joga bonito, and not like the boring Barcelona of the Champions League final. Arsenal is just excellent. Good keeper with spectacular saves, spectacular goals from Henry and now goals from 30-40 metres from Rosicky.

Answer 9

Don't listen to these muppets, support WEST HAM UNITED. The mighty Hammers out played Liverpool in the F.A. cup final and it was only Steve Gerrard who saved Liverpool from certain defeat. Check out www.whufc.co also watch the movie titled Green Street Hooligans. I'm sure you'll make the right choice. I'm West Ham til I die.

Answer 10

Choose Liverpool they are heaps better than arsenal and if you want to choose a club from the top of the table to support you go for it, it`s nothing to do with anyone else

Answer 11

Wigan Athletic