A horrible answer. What do you think?

Question

When i posted the question: "People are cold, especially when it comes to defend israel.WATCH OUT : Disgusting Pictures?" on yahoo answers where i have a link that shows pictures of dead children killed by Israel, a person called: "S. Weinstein" replied with the following:
"I am a Jew and was always raised to believe Gentiles are nothing but animals. Your pictures do not make me sick or sad. Jews are the chosen people and deserve to have everything we have plus more. It was Hezzbolah that is to blame for the new war. They are terrorists and God is giving Jews the power to destroy anyone who comes in our path. The pictures are nothing but dead animals. I think many Jews I know would feel the same way. "

What do you think? Is this acceptable or despicable to you? The link is below:
http://fromisraeltolebanon.info/

Answer 1

The pictures are terrible! I couldn't even finish looking at the them. But S. Weinstein's reply cannot be described as anything more than EVIL. Only an evil person would think and say such things. It doesn't matter how you were raised, a person CAN think for themselves and is always born with the capability to have compasion for other people......God said "Love one another"!

Answer 2

It may not be the answer you like, but it is useful in one way. It helps you understand the mindset of some Jews. But by reading other answers, I can see that there are many Jews who would disagree with that person.

I think it's sad that that person has been raised that way. But I think it is a good answer - Only because it gives insight into the mind of another. I, personally, do not believe that any human should be called an animal unless they have done something atrocious (such as murdering innocent children for pleasure).

edit: I also want to clarify that I don't like that answer either. Very insightful, but soooooo wrong.

Answer 3

The wonderful thing about this country is that we are free to believe and think as we wish. Although I don't agree with that person's opinion, they are FREE to voice their opinion.

I happen to have been raised Jewish, and have actually been to Israel.

Personally I don't believe in war, and wish there was a better way. Part of the problem with the internet is the ability to show pictures such as these. There have been so many wars in our Country's history, and I am thankful there aren't any pictures from them. Innocent people and children will always be killed in wars. Just the way it is.

Answer 4

I think you will find it is complicated, and there are people at all ends.

There are extremists everywhere. I agree that Israel’s response is definitely out of proportion for the initial attacks. They are definitely pursuing their own agenda here. However, how do you negotiate or get on with a group that feels you have no right to exist? Frankly, I think that 90% of the people out there are being held to hostage of the fanatics. On both sides. Your poster could be anyone – why assume he is Jewish. I would rather say that he is the animal – no God would support what he has to say – be happy that he is at least going to hell when he dies.

The whole situation is a right mess!

Answer 5

I am jewish i know that most jews wouldnt feel that way that is wrong and sick prob some idiot. but i have seen the pictures and they made me sick. i dont know where they came from but i know one thing israel would never commit such atrocities. therefore i can only say that it is a sick attempt to discredit israel ,They probably collected pics from things not to do with israel ,horrible accidents that happened bet them.
im sure this has happened many times bf ,although i rarely go on moslem sites so i wouldnt know but this i do know fact : jewish boy just viciously attacked by moslem gang a jewish soldier goes to rescue him reporter took a photograph of the bloodied boy with the soldier near him saying that the soldier had attacked the boy.thats just one instance .

the more mild shots may be unavoidable casualties of war but the other pictures are evil israel doesent do that!! almost all

Answer 6

Unfortunately, there are no boundaries, religious or nationality, to stupidity and bigotry. For every S Wienstein, theres a A. Muhammed and a Bubba Goodolboy, and on and on spewing hate.
The problems in the Middle East are very complex, with no right or wrong answers, and very hard solutions. Turmoil has existed there for thousands of years. Hopefully some day they will all live together with mutual respect, but dont hold your breath.

Answer 7

it is extreme but you know what israel dropped leaflets before they bombed telling the people to get out...so try to swallow that...I am not jewish but they do have a right to be there. THey won that land after ww11 and again in 1967 the middle east needs to accept that they arent going anywhere!! ANd that website is really what is descpiable those hezzbolah f.u.c.ks. kill their own people all the time where are those pictures?

Answer 8

No its NOT acceptable to me,far from it! It IS despicable,and I'm absolutely appalled by it! The response you got was also despicable! The whole thing makes me sick to my stomach,that includes the discusting response you got from "S.Weinstein"
With the kind of response you got, plus that website,is it any wonder why there is so much trouble there? War is evil. Sadly there really are no winners.

Answer 9

the zionists stole the land of the palestinians. that is the root of the problems in the middle east.

before the zionists came to palestine, the few jews that were there got a long pretty well with the palestinians.

Answer 10

Seems to me, his answer is no more or less terrible, than you posting horrible pictures of dead children & asking for comments about it.

If ya don't want know people's true opinions, then don't ask!