Why do hindus think that muslims have contributed nothing to India?

Question

Read this

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AqNi7grBoluHMCJfHFpYOK_sy6IX?qid=20060719125258AAeLPPq

Why do hindus always claim that muslims have contributed nothing to India? Indias muslim president was behind India nuclear programme. The Taj Mahal was built by a muslim.

Many aspects of indian culture such as their food, clothes are influenced by muslims. Even the urdu language which is always used in songs and in entertainement is influenced by muslims.

So why do they keep saying that muslims have contributed nothing?

For those of you saying that hindus don't believe in violence, wake up.

Who destroyed the babri masjid? Who killed more than 2000 muslims in gujarat?

Get out of your fantasy world.

And btw why did the BJP react so strongly to the report that the train incident was an accident? Did they just want an excuse to kill more muslims?

Answer 1

You seem to be spreading hatred against india or Hindus. Just because the hindus, though they are majority and original people of the land, have enough of tolerance and some of you are taking undue advantage of it.

Go back to the History books.. you will find the answers to every question.

Taj Mahal was built by Muslim.. mmmm... what a conveinience in coverting a shiva temple of Tejo Mahal into burrial ground for a dead body !.

and who said they have contributed nothing to India. In fact, the whole world will accept for their contribution in creating terrorist activities across the globe - not just India.

Grow up - have life, do something good - at least once in life.

Cheers

Answer 2

India is a hindu country with the head of state, the president a muslim. Where in the world have you seen this and when?

Who cares what nuclear program he developed? It was because muslims are always attacking india that india has to invest in weaponry. Get it straight. India being a hindu country does not believe in violence. No killing unless to defend.
This money in nuclear power could have been used to improve the lives of some poor kids. But no we have to protect our selves from muslims in our own country.

Taj Mahal by a muslim? DO you think he built it? No hindus built it and he watched. And then he cut their hands off so no other Taj Mahal could be built. Who the hell cares about the Taj if it is used as an excuse of contribution by muslims. It is only a mausoleum which islam does not allow.

I reinforce the statement in your questions. Muslims have contributed nothing. They have stolen all the gold and the gems and valuables, ruled india and taxed indians to take to middle east ( you see they had not found cars or oil yet ) and captured women and children as slaves. The muslims then slowly started stealing land. Afghanistan, Pakistan and bangladesh

Muslims killed millions of people.

Who the hell cares about Abdul Kalam, who is an ignorant man and should have never become president if he was intelligent, and the Taj Mahal? The muslims take our land, live off our tax money and have children like rabbits. They teach hindus to eat meat and have slaughter houses in our holy cities.

Ignorance is bliss.

Give me something better.

Answer 3

Who ever told muslims havent contributed anything to India?

You know right just a few days ago they blew up some bombs and contributed to the society by reducing the India's population. And havent they been doing this from time they ever stepped into the soil of India..

And do you know the black period in Indian history. Thats after the muslim invasion. Like it or not, accept it or not, Muslims were just invaders into India just as much British were. And their brutality still continues.

Why did they ever chose to be in a secular state as India without going to Pakistan (the country to which they still feel loyal to than India, a partition which they just wanted for their people) if they dont like a Hindu procession pass by in their streets when they cant respect the feeling of majority Indians.

The majority Indians , the Hindus, support anything good, whether it is Muslim or not. We are proud of our president who is a Muslim. Do you think in any Muslim country they will let a Hindu be president. With all the freedom all that the Muslims want is partition( if not why would they ask for seperate Kashmir when they have freedom even to be a president!).

I do not think much of south Indian food has any influence of Mughals. Pure south Indian food is a lot healthier. But if you thought you just want a credit for your food and clothing, take responsibility for all the fighting thats going on around in the name of Islam in the land of India. Stop the terrorism. Stop the fanaticism. Spread around good values instead of still dividing further. Then everone will have time to remember the naan and whatever.

Some of the Muslims in India are highly fanatical, who thinks it haram even to have a Hindu friend! And some mingle in the front a bit better but at the back have all wild thoughts against Hindus. And there are some Muslims who are really nice, who see humanity beyond religion. I am blessed with some such nice Muslim friends. And they have contributed a lot to India than the food and clothing, they have contributed Peace and love.

So as a Hindu I wouldnt say Muslims in India never contributed anything.

Anyway lets get over this. Muslims have contributed and should contribute much more good to India and India is a secular country. Lets speak beyond religion and bring our country forward.

Answer 4

Muslims have contributed no doubt but stop for a moment and think about the present rather than the past.If they want to continue to contribute,let it be positive contribution and not retribution under the name of fanaticism.If rationality and humanity can make place in the Muslim psyche that by itself would be the biggest contribution to humankind.

Answer 5

Well if it makes you feel any better i am a Hindu and i judge people individually not by groups or religion.

P.S. i think Muslims have contributed to India as much as Hindus. and don't believe that survey because if it was true India wouldn't have a MUSLIM president.

Answer 6

Y DO MUSLIMS THINK THAT HINDUS DISCRIMINATE THEM>>>HINDUS R MORE SECULAR THEN MUSLIMS R (fact).THOUGH MUSLIMS IN ALL ISLAMIC NATIONS KILL AND DO WORST THINGS WITH kafirs NON MUSLIMS INDIA DOES NOT DO THE SAME> V SHOULD ALL LIVE LIKE BROTHERS AND HELP INDIA TO PROGRESS >EVERY MUSLIM SHOULD HAVE THOUGHTS LIKES UR WASHED AWAY >>>WE R INDIA NEITHERS MUSLIMS NOR HINDUS?(can u think in this way)

Answer 7

This issue could be debate-able at any length.

In short, like in any other community, a few handful resident vested interests in each community have been destroying the good deeds of their fellow countrymen. No community is exception to this.

Answer 8

their contribution to india is akbar the great and many monuments in the past.

Now it is APJ Abdul Kalam President of India

yes many more

Answer 9

well, u r livin in a bubble, the times hav gone ahead of what u r talkin about, hindus Dont think that way, ok?! its misconceived and misinterpreted, now stop being racist.

Answer 10

ITS A LONG STORY BETWEEN HINDUS AND MUSLIMS