Is This a Good Trade? Do i have a good team?

Question

this is my team right now....

Jake Plummer
Torry Holt
Randy Moss
Rod Smith
Shawn Alexander
Corey Dillon
Chris Cooley
P. Rivers
L. Coles
j. Stevens
J. Lewis

S.Graham
J. Reed

Chicago
New England

Those are all my guys but this other guy made a trade to me and im not sure to accept it or not, this was the trade....

Big Ben ,A. Boldin , J.Walker , W. McGahee FOR Shawn Alexander

4 guys for 1, but Shawn is pretty good, is it a good trade? And what do you think of my team?

Answer 1

Do not trade accept this trade. Unless you are forced to because of injuries, you never want to trade a great player for multiple average to good ones. You team is good, but has some weaknesses. You need help at QB but Big Ben isn't any improvement over Plummer. Hold out for a better offer and don't listen to the others telling you to dump players. I agree that Lewis should be starting instead of Dillon but Dillon will be a nice stop gap for your bye weeks and should either starter get hurt. Do not trade Moss. He played injured all last year but is finally healthy. He should have a good season and fantasy-wise, look what Brooks was able to do with Joe Horn...who is nowhere near the player that Moss is. You are carrying quite a few extra players at the weaker positions. Don't be afraid to drop some of the extras if needed to pick up some depth at RB and WR.

Answer 2

You can't start all the guys you are trading for. Only Boldin would most likely be a starter for you besides McGahee(who would be taking SA's spot).
I think its a bad move.
Don't listen to guys that have 10 serious fantasy teams. A serious fantasy person wouldn't have 10 teams because you couldn't actually get a grip on each team.
Don't trade studs for quantity. That is a rule you should always follow.

Answer 3

Ok listen this is what I would do and I play serious fantasy leagues like I have ten of them already. Honestly your teams not that great ok heres the scoop yah Big Ben's coming back but he's still weak hes not all the way healthy. Shaun Alexander is a great back for fantasy theres no beating him and jamal lewis is your second back this year not dillon. With McNair in Baltimore it opens up the running game for Lewis, he will be back to himself this year trust me. As far as moss and rod smith, you should try and dump them get Steve Smith, best reciever for fantasy he returns kicks, sometimes punts and hes a thousand yard reciever. Dump dillon too get someone like Reggie Bush no one took Reggie high this year because they think hes gonna play split back , well he will but for a small amount of time. Last thing you say dump Moss, I say yes you were dumb for getting him in the first place AARON BROOKS IS THROWING THE BALL before it gets to moss it will be in the ground or in the defenders hands. No trade.

Answer 4

basically occurred... and that i will continuously be a Manny fan. he's exciting and exciting and a damn solid hitter... the terrific Righty in the activity and he became into tailor made for Fenway... Its a shame that the two those obdurate egos had to harm eachother like they did, the pink Sox administration and Manny. are you asking reason you study the writing on the wall that Tek isn't gonna have an straightforward bargin with the pink Sox this autumn? he's gonna choose years... the pink Sox not at all provide years. i do no longer hate Damon as much as I used to, i think of the pink Sox botched that one, he's barely been to the DL as quickly as considering he left Boston...and he became into the face of the team, and a catalist for the offense... they even have not had a definate leadoff catalist considering he left... Ellsbury nevertheless desires yet another 365 days or so... while that commerce went down i became into pissed! Yankees continuously try this tho. Nomar, they have been on condition that one precise... Nomar is valueless now, has been considering spring 04. i do no longer think of all people in Boston likes Nomar anymore. i'm dying to make certain what Braves followers say to this question...

Answer 5

I find it hard to believe that anyone can give you an accurate answer without knowing the settings in your particular league. This may be a great team in some leagues...but a below average team in others...depending on the settings.

Answer 6

It does sound tempting because it will give you depth

if you do it drop stevens reed and rivers

then trade boldin and dillon for a better runningback

Answer 7

Hold on to Alexander, but get rid of Dillon. When he plays, he's OK, but Bellichek gets cute with his injured players and announces they'll play, but they don't. S.O.B. cost me a spot in the playoffs last year.

Answer 8

TAKE THE DEAL THE 4 HE OFFERS WILL OUT SCORE ALEXANDER. 2 GOOD RECEIVER AND 1 DECENT RB AND BIG BEN IS BETTER THAN RIVERS. GO FOR IT

Answer 9

dont take the trade... and ur team looks very good

Answer 10

Boats.