English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

2006-07-19 00:34:22 · 4 answers · asked by zeph7r 1 in Politics & Government Other - Politics & Government

People I mean ROC which is Taiwan, and not PRC (People's Republic of China) which rules mainland China. The permanent seat at the UN security council you are talking about was occupied by ROC until 1979 when it was substituted for a PRC seat wich the UN considered represented the country of China. Now the PRC considers the ROC a rebel province, and I KNOW Taiwan was not yet admitted to join the UN as a country. My question is if its sovereignty is ractified by the UN?

2006-07-19 00:54:02 · update #1

4 answers

The Republic of China on Taiwan is not a sovereign nation. According to international law, four criteria are generally required (1) defined territory, (2) permanent population, (3) government, and (4) the capacity to conduct foreign relations.

However, most researchers overlook the fact that these criteria have to be more than just physically present, they have to conform to "legal standards." Based on any reasonable definition of legal requirements, the ROC on Taiwan has neither defined territory nor a permanent population.

This is because in the post-war peace treaty of April 28, 1952, Japan renounced the territorial sovereignty of Taiwan, but the ROC was not designated as the "receiving country." Hence, the ROC does not have any legal claim to "territorial title" of Taiwan. Without such a claim, there is also no legal basis for considering that native Taiwanese persons are ROC citizens.

In fact, mass naturalization of native Taiwanese persons as "ROC citizens" in Taiwan is based on a January 1946 order by the ROC military authorities. Under international law, the surrender of Japanese troops on Oct. 25, 1945, merely marks the beginning of the military occupation of Taiwan, and mass naturalization of the local civilian populace under such circumstances is a war crime.

2006-07-20 19:07:43 · answer #1 · answered by IR-student 3 · 0 0

yes this is correct, China was an original member of the security council and they are a permanent modern member

2006-07-19 00:44:38 · answer #2 · answered by stutznut23 2 · 0 0

of course, they are even a permanent member on the Security Council if I remember right.

2006-07-19 00:38:35 · answer #3 · answered by John J 6 · 0 0

properly its as a lot because the individuals who stay in a a particular region to come back to a decision for themselves, search for political representation and then pursue their declare. you could attempt it your self - ascertain that the land you proceed to exist is your own usa. then you definately make a political case to the authorities, and in the journey that they reject it declare warfare. then you definately pick to convince different international places that you're quite are a rustic on your own top and let them to open an embassy on your territory and open an embassy in theirs. very few international places will settle on your position because it ought to have detrimental political implications with their relationship on your 'mom usa'. in case you inspect Taiwan, very few international places have diplomatic kin with Taiwan (neither the U. S., Russia or the ecu have diplomatic kin with them). Taiwan has no position on the UN. it may well be stated that the positions of lines on a map that outline any usa politically are quite arbitrary and meaningless. The 'One China' coverage is only a political position - you're free to settle for it or reject it. Write on your political representative.

2016-12-01 21:52:38 · answer #4 · answered by ambach 3 · 0 0

fedest.com, questions and answers